Tax compliance and non-deterrence approach: a systematic review

Abstract

PurposeThis research systematically reviewed studies on tax compliance based on five determinants consisting of tax services, trust in government, personal norm, social norm and religiosity.Design/methodology/approachThe research used a vote-counting method to synthesize 279 studies consisting of 160 empirical studies and 119 non-empirical studies conducted from 1946 until 2017.FindingsThe research has made a relatively robust conclusion related to the impacts of determinant factors on tax compliance. Tax service and trust in government are the most critical factors to increase tax compliance. Personal norm, social norm and religiosity encourage tax compliance, yet the influence is not as strong as expected.Practical implicationsThis research suggests that improving tax service and government trust are more effective and relatively easier to implement than developing the taxpayers' positive behaviors.Originality/valueSeveral studies conducted to synthesize the impacts of determinant factors on tax compliance were only limited to the empirical research which provided sufficient statistical data. On the other hand, there were many substantial research types discussing tax compliance without involving statistical numbers. The facts have distorted the complete picture of tax compliance. Recently, no synthesis studies have comprehensively combined and compared the empirical with non-empirical research based on the related theories. Thus, the synthesis studies that discuss tax compliance based on non-deterrence approach are still limited.

Tax Compliance in Indonesian MSMEs: Key Factors Explored

“…Furthermore, knowing the consequences of non-compliance, such as penalties and legal actions, can also serve as a deterrent and motivate MSME owners to fulfil their tax obligations (Dularif & Rustiarini, 2022). This knowledge acts as a guiding force, helping MSME owners navigate the complex tax system and enabling them to fulfil their responsibilities as responsible citizens (Subroto, 2020).…”

Why do people give to their governments? Lab‐in‐the‐field evidence on the role of norms, social information, and political support

“…Although our regression analysis below will test hypotheses H3 to H5, we note as an aside that an extensive literature on tax compliance hints that citizens' trust in their governments, as well as their perceptions about the extent of public waste and corruption, affect the decision to evade taxes (Taliercio, 2004; Torgler, 2005; Bodea & LeBas, 2016; Prichard, 2018; Dularif & Rustiarini, 2021; Kouamé, 2021). This is perhaps relevant, as norms might be a relevant part of tax morale, in which case our research on giving to the government could also be relevant for tax compliance, at least from a behavioral perspective.…”

Gross turnover assessment and tax compliance in Uganda’s small businesses: a deep inquiry on the certainty of presumptive tax law

“…Previous studies on tax compliance have applied the deterrence theory (Dularif and Rustiarini, 2021), the theory of planned action/reasoned action (Bani-Khalid et al , 2022; Kiconco et al , 2019; Sadress et al , 2019), social-economic model of sales (Alshira'h et al , 2020), guilt and shame theory (Erard and Feinstein, 1994), game theory (Tyler, 2012; Levi, 1997). No previous study has applied the enmeshment theory in investigating tax compliance.…”