Task-shifting and task-sharing initiatives to improve community nutrition services, lessons from Ethiopia

Abstract

Introduction: The USAID Transform: Primary Health Care project is working on preventing maternal and child deaths in Ethiopia. As part of its effort, the project is supporting the government in its endeavor in improving nutrition service coverage and quality. More than 90% of the communities are accessing nutrition and health services at health posts where trained health extension workers (HEWs) provide services. ‘Workload’ in the HEWs was identified as critical challenge and in response, a small scale task-shifting task-sharing initiative was tested in two selected health posts. Tasks related to monthly acute malnutrition screening, monthly GMP, and cooking demonstration were shifted completely from the HEWs to a voluntary community health workers. The tasks of tracing and linking of targeted children for VAS and deworming were also shared by the CHWs, while the actual provision of the drugs were done by the HEWs. This study focuses on the results of this initiative. Methodology: A quasi-experimental method with pretest-posttest design is used to measure the outcomes of the initiative. The findings of the house-to-house survey done after eight months of the implementation of the initiative are compared with that of the baseline. This is triangulated with the findings of record reviews and in-depth interviews. Result: A total of 243 (116 girls) and 219 (112 girls) under-five children were identified at the baseline and at the second round house-to-house surveys respectively. Monthly screening coverage for acute malnutrition has improved from 8% at baseline to 99%. The percentage of children supplemented with vitamin-A during the six months prior to the survey reached 97% from the baseline status of 23%. Growth monitoring and promotion (GMP) participation rate has also improved from 5–96%. Recounting and comparing the coverages reported by the health facilities from source document was not possible at baseline due to incomplete documentation. After the introduction of the initiative, the documentation has improved and the discrepancy between the reported, the recorded and the survey data for the three services narrowed down to a range of 1% difference for VAS, to 6% for acute malnutrition screening. Conclusion: Nutrition services in Ethiopia heavily depend on the productivity of the health extension program (HEP) which is currently struggling with several challenges with the workload being among the critical bottlenecks. The results of this study shows that coverage and quality of essential nutrition services can be improved if workload challenges are recognized and addressed through carefully designed task-shifting and task-sharing initiatives. The marked discrepancies among the reported, the recorded and the actual coverages shows that monitoring nutrition services through the routine information system could be misleading. Recommendations: Efforts to improve community nutrition services should recognize heavy workload in the HEP as a critical challenge. This initiative should be scaled up with continuous learning including on its impact on the productivity of HEWs and CHWs. Investigating and addressing nutrition data quality should also be among the top priorities as the current status is often seen to be unacceptable.

Perceived Worries and Spirituality: A Mixed Methods Study of the Primary Caregiver Well-Being of Orphan and Vulnerable Children in Ethiopia

“…For example, the country's food insecurity accounted for 45% of child deaths. Globally, Ethiopia also has the second-highest population of orphans and vulnerable children [30,31]. Due to poverty, a high unemployment rate, urbanization, migration, internal displacement, ethnic conflicts, and global changes, the traditional support system is becoming fragile and inviting humanitarian organizations to engage in crisis mitigation, relief, and community development interventions [28,31].…”

“…Due to poverty, a high unemployment rate, urbanization, migration, internal displacement, ethnic conflicts, and global changes, the traditional support system is becoming fragile and inviting humanitarian organizations to engage in crisis mitigation, relief, and community development interventions [28,31]. However, between 2021 and the beginning of 2023, until the peace agreement between the federal government of Ethiopia and Northern Tigrayan leaders, which was led by the US government and the African Union, the condition of the IDP worsened, coupled with an extreme increase in living standards, and drought affected over 20 million people, a situation currently (i.e., 2023) involving multiple forms of international humanitarian aid for crisis and relief mitigation [26,30].…”

Effect of enhanced nutrition services with community‐based nutrition services on the diet quality of young children in Ethiopia

“…The SURE was a multi-sectoral government-led programme that integrated health and agriculture sector service delivery for nutrition outcomes. It was a complex intervention that expanded the CBN services through integration with selected agricultural services, thus enhancing the standard CBN programme (Abebe et al, 2012).…”