Background: TgSUB1 is a subtilisin protease that trims invasion proteins on the surface of Toxoplasma gondii. Results: TgMIC5 suppresses TgSUB1 activity and structurally mimics a subtilisin prodomain, suggesting a mechanism for inhibition. Conclusion: The C-terminal region of TgMIC5 is responsible for inhibition of TgSUB1. Significance: We identify a novel subtilisin propeptide mimic.