Taming Deep Uncertainty: The Potential of Pragmatist Principles for Understanding and Improving Strategic Crisis Management

Abstract

Modern societies are increasingly faced with “unknown unknowns,” Black Swans, and mega-crises. Both public and corporate leaders find it deeply challenging to respond to these crisis events. Existing approaches and tools to cope with crisis-induced uncertainty are of little help in these dynamic environments. This article explores how the principles of Pragmatism may provide the building blocks for a theory of effective strategic crisis management. We argue that these principles, formulated by a group of American philosophers in a time of deep uncertainty, provide a way of thinking that will help practitioners prepare for, and deal with, emerging risks, crises, and disasters.

Covid-19 and entrepreneurship education: Implications for advancing research and practice

“…Crisis are complex and their effects are felt immediately but also over a long period of time ( Ansell and Boin, 2019 ). The COVID-19 crisis was a low-probability event that was unpredictable.…”

How Times of Crisis Serve as a Catalyst for Creative Action: An Agentic Perspective

“…The term crisis has its roots in the ancient Greek word Kríno , which means to judge or decide, and although crisis has come to mean different things in different disciplines it typically implies that decisive action is needed to avoid potentially negative consequences associated with the crisis situation. Taking action in times of crisis, however, is challenging because such experiences are shot through with uncertainty ( Ansell and Boin, 2019 ; Beghetto, 2020 ; Cohen and Cromwell, 2020 ). We can thereby define a time of crisis as an experience of profound uncertainty coupled with a sense of urgency to take action to minimize or avoid potential negative outcomes .…”

Business not as usual: how multisectoral collaboration can promote transformative change for health and sustainable development

“…This common “logic of inquiry” was elaborated by Dewey in pragmatist philosophy as a systematic way to support societal learning and advancement 20. It was applied in a “transactive rationality model” for public policy and administration,21 and in other contexts including environmental policy assessment24 and strategic crisis management 25…”