The lack of characterizations of the adsorption capability toward intermediates during reactions causes difficulties in determining the structural optimization principle of the catalysts for the 2-electron oxygen reduction reaction (2e − ORR). Here, a Tafel−θ method is proposed to evaluate the surface coverage (θ) of important intermediates (*OOH and *OH) on the material surface and further help optimize the catalyst. With the assistance of Tafel−θ analysis, a Zn nanoparticle incorporated oxygen-doped carbon (Zn NP -O-C) catalyst with high 2e − ORR performance (onset of ∼0.57 V and selectivity of >90.4%) in neutral media was achieved. Both the theoretical calculation and characterization results are consistent with the Tafel−θ deduction, revealing that an appropriate ratio of Zn nanoparticles and bridging O can optimize the *OOH adsorption/desorption strength of the adjacent carbon site. This study not only provides an advanced Zn NP -O-C catalyst for electrochemical H 2 O 2 production but also proposes a fast and precise method for the comprehensive assessment of future catalysts.