TAD-like single-cell domain structures exist on both active and inactive X chromosomes and persist under epigenetic perturbations

Abstract

Background: Topologically associating domains (TADs) are important building blocks of three-dimensional genome architectures. The formation of TADs was shown to depend on cohesin in a loop-extrusion mechanism. Recently, advances in an image-based spatial genomics technique known as chromatin tracing led to the discovery of cohesin-independent TAD-like structures, also known as single-cell domains - highly variant self-interacting chromatin domains with boundaries that occasionally overlap with TAD boundaries but tend to differ among single cells and among single chromosome copies. Several recent computational modeling studies suggest that single-cell variations of epigenetic profiles may underlie the formation of the single-cell domains. Results: Here we use chromatin tracing to visualize in female human cells the fine-scale chromatin folding of inactive and active X chromosomes, which are known to have distinct global epigenetic landscapes and distinct population-averaged TAD profiles, with inactive X chromosomes largely devoid of TADs and cohesin. We show that both inactive and active X chromosomes possess highly variant single-cell domains across the same genomic region despite the fact that only active X chromosomes show clear TAD structures at the population level. These X chromosome single-cell domains exist in distinct cell lines. Perturbations of major epigenetic components did not significantly affect the frequency or strength of the single-cell domains. Increased chromatin compaction of inactive X chromosomes occurs at a length scale above that of the single-cell domains. Conclusions: In sum, this study suggests that single-cell domains are genome architecture building blocks independent of variations in major epigenetic landscapes.

Single-cell nuclear architecture across cell types in the mouse brain

“…6C). A recent observation of heterogeneous single-cell domain structures in the Xa and Xi even under epigenetic perturbations ( 34 ) further supports our finding in the Xa and Xi. Taken together, although the Xa and Xi show very different epigenetic states and ensemble-averaged chromosome conformation, they can share similar underlying single-cell domain structures with different relative conformational preferences at the submegabase scale.…”

A maximum-entropy model to predict 3D structural ensembles of chromatins from pairwise distances: Applications to Interphase Chromosomes and Structural Variants

“…TAD-like patterns in single cell: A most interesting finding in the imaging experiments [34] is that even in a single cell, domain-like or TAD-like structures may be discerned, even in inactive X chromosomes whose ensemble Hi-C map is rather structureless [57]. These signatures are manifested as TAD-like patterns in the pairwise distance matrix (see the left panels for two cells in Figure 4B in [34]).…”

A maximum-entropy model to predict 3D structural ensembles of chromatins from pairwise distances: Applications to Interphase Chromosomes and Structural Variants

“…TAD-like patterns in single cell: Imaging experiments [47] show that even in a single cell, domain-like or TAD-like structures may be discerned, even in inactive X chromosomes whose ensemble Hi-C map appears to be featureless [72]. These signatures are manifested as TADlike patterns in the pairwise distance matrix (see the left panels for two cells in Figure 4B in [47]).…”