Systems Engineering for the Energy Transition: Potential Contributions and Limitations

Abstract

Systems engineering finds its origin in analyzing and exploring complicated technical systems. In this positioning paper, we set out to discuss the value and limitations of a Systems Engineering approach in its contribution to societal challenges, notably the energy transition. We conceptualize the energy system as a sociotechnical system. We specifically explore stakeholders and their roles, agency, and acceptance. We illustrate the relevance by a case at the municipal level that shows the relevance of acceptance, pluralism, distributed agency, context, and process aspects. The municipality is still in a phase of exploration and conceptualization. Systems Engineering can be of great value in this phase to explore the problem and solution space. However, to make the most of this requires that Systems Engineering addresses policy making, distributed agency, and complexity. We discuss the challenges this poses for the traditional Systems Engineering approach; we indicate several potential strategies to address these challenges, and we show two fields that can help clarify how to address these challenges: transition studies and sustainability assessment.

Enhancing Competency and Industry Integration: A Case Study of Collaborative Systems Engineering Education for Future Success

“…Systems engineering is one of the disciplines that can facilitate the sustainability transition [39,56]. Kirkels et al [57] discussed the potential contributions of systems engineering together with limitations. They pointed to transition studies and sustainability assessment as fields to assist systems engineering in addressing sustainability.…”

Ready for the Road? A Socio-Technical Investigation of Fire Safety Improvement Options for Lithium-Ion Traction Batteries

“…In doing so, we respond to the recent call for more transdisciplinary research and integrative approaches in socio-technical studies on transitions [36][37][38], as well as in systems engineering to address large societal challenges [39,40]. Also, with this approach, we avoid the drawbacks of more traditional socio-technical studies that typically draw on descriptive, qualitative case studies that hardly operationalize technical (im)possibilities and have limited forward orientation.…”

Systems engineering applied to urban planning and development: A review and research agenda

“…Systems engineering is well-equipped to support both. Two other such areas are the transition to a low-carbon energy system144 and general urban climate resilience as environmental and social perturbations intensify in the coming decades. Recent years have seen promising efforts made in this vein.…”