Systematic thematic review of e-health research in the Gulf Cooperation Council (Arabian Gulf): Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates

Abstract

Introduction The Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC or 'Arabian Gulf'), comprising Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates, is a political organization sharing a common history and culture. All GCC nations have made substantial investments in telecommunications and electronic health infrastructure since 2000. Methods We conducted a literature search in English and Arabic on peer-reviewed e-health research up to December 2014 originating in the GCC. The objective was to retrieve all research on e-health in the GCC and to categorize and analyse it qualitatively to reveal the current state of e-health research and development in the region. Inclusion criteria included peer-reviewed articles, books, book chapters, conference papers and graduate theses written on e-health in the GCC. Blogs, health websites and non-peer-reviewed literature were excluded. Results Three hundred and six articles were retrieved, categorized and analysed qualitatively to reveal the state of e-health research in the GCC. Both country-specific and GCC-wide major themes were identified using NVivo 10.0 qualitative software and summarized. The most common type of study was an overview (35.0%), with common study designs of case studies (26.8%) and descriptive articles (46.4%). Significant themes were: prospective national benefits from e-health, implementation and satisfaction with electronic health records, online technologies in medical education, innovative systems (case studies), and information security and personal health information. Discussion This is the first comprehensive analytical literature review of e-health in the GCC. Important research gaps were identified: few cost-benefit analyses, controlled interventional studies, or research targeting gender and religious issues were retrieved.

Telemedicine in Arab Countries: Innovation, Research Trends, and Way Forward

“…We identified important research gaps in digital health research based on our scientometric analyses (Figure 7), also corroborated by previous research (10,26): a) Trial data: We found a lack of controlled trials of medical devices, algorithms, and telemedicine technology in hospital centers in the Arab world. If we are to estimate precise effect sizes for these technologies, it is important to develop this field of research in these countries.…”

Electronic Mental Health as an Option for Egyptian Psychiatry: Cross-Sectional Study

“…In parallel, the World Health Organization has produced a web-based intervention called “Step-by-Step” to treat symptoms of depression, which is currently being tested in Lebanon with cultural and contextual adaptations [ 36 ]. Similarly, in Saudi Arabia, a 10-year national eHealth program was launched in 2011 with the aim of developing clinical automation, telecommunication infrastructure, and a nationwide eHealth record system [ 43 ]. In Egypt, the use of online consultations in specific fields, such as dermatology and psychiatry, is starting to develop [ 28 , 44 ].…”

Understanding health information management practices in public hospitals in Kuwait

“…However, the current levels of adoption and maturity of health informatics solutions in Kuwait are limited (Weber et al, 2017). While some hospitals have some electronic solutions such as EHRs or laboratory information system, these solutions are operating in a silo and do not interface with other Additionally, healthcare institutions should be involved in continuous assessments to uncover their digital health maturity.…”

“…As highlighted from the surveyors’ comments, organisations that adopted and deployed integrated informatics solutions, such as EHRs, had better scores compared with their peers who did not. However, the current levels of adoption and maturity of health informatics solutions in Kuwait are limited (Weber et al, 2017). While some hospitals had some electronic solutions such as EHRs or laboratory information system, these solutions were operating in a silo and did not interface with other systems in or outside the hospital.…”

“…To better manage health information, Kuwait has made significant investments in the digital health infrastructure since 2000 (Weber et al, 2017). A variety of health IT solutions have been implemented at MoH facilities (Alhuwail and Barnes, 2011), including EHRs at primary healthcare centers (Al-Azmi et al, 2006;Al-Jafar, 2013) and hospitals (Alquraini et al, 2007), as well as Picture Archiving and Communication Systems (Buabbas et al, 2016).…”