Systematic racist violence in Russia between ‘hate crime’ and ‘ethnic conflict’

Abstract

Racist violence in Russia has recently become a subject of interest to scholars and analysts of Russian politics. What are the similarities and differences between racist violence in Russia and the West? How does the level of Russian racist violence compare to other societies? Do racist hate groups in Russia have similar origins to groups in the West? This article considers these questions. I first demonstrate that Russia is indeed the most dangerous country in Europe for ethnic minorities, and argue that such violence is more 'systematic' (structured, ideologically coherent, patterned) than in other developed societies. The high level of violence against ethnic minorities in Russia is 'over-determined' by a combination of post-Soviet social and economic social changes, the brutalizing consequences of a long counter-insurgency campaign, and government passivity (and sometimes complicity) in the face of racist violence and hate speech. Thus, Russia's systematic racist violence is analytically closer to outright ethnic conflict than to a form of criminal deviance that could aptly be termed 'hate crime'.

Civil Society, ‘Traditional Values’ and LGBT Resistance to Heteronormative Rights Hegemony: Analysis of the UN Universal Periodic Review in the Russian Federation

“…the joint third-ranked frame. In turn, and reflecting widespread inequalities facing minorities (Arnold 2015;Pankratova & Pankratov 2016), '(anti)-discrimination' is the other third-ranked frame, both with 13%.…”

The Beautiful Game

“…Russia did not acquire an overseas empire in Africa or Asia as did other European powers, and consequently today maintains a much more homogenous society than many of its peers in Europe. While there is ethnic diversity in Russia, distance, and the existence of systems of residency permits during both the Tsarist and Soviet periods, have not facilitated individual mixing in the same way as in Western societies (Arnold 2015). Consequently, the country's entrance into the modern capitalist and globalized world has seen the development of widespread racism and high levels of racist violence (Larys and Mares 2011; Arnold and Markowitz 2018).…”

Violence Exposure, Posttraumatic Stress, and Subjective Well-Being in a Sample of Russian Adults: A Facebook-Based Study

“…Most of the existing research on violence in Russia published in the international journals roughly falls into the two following categories. The first includes papers on political, ethnic violence, and human rights violations (Arnold, 2015; van der Vet & Lyytikäinen, 2015). The second describes victimization experiences in highly vulnerable populations such as migrant workers (Weine, Bahromov, Loue, & Owens, 2012), illicit drug users (Lunze, Lunze, Raj, & Samet, 2015), and commercial sex workers (Decker et al, 2014).…”