Systematic Identification of Housekeeping Genes Possibly Used as References in Caenorhabditis elegans by Large-Scale Data Integration

Abstract

For accurate gene expression quantification, normalization of gene expression data against reliable reference genes is required. It is known that the expression levels of commonly used reference genes vary considerably under different experimental conditions, and therefore, their use for data normalization is limited. In this study, an unbiased identification of reference genes in Caenorhabditis elegans was performed based on 145 microarray datasets (2296 gene array samples) covering different developmental stages, different tissues, drug treatments, lifestyle, and various stresses. As a result, thirteen housekeeping genes (rps-23, rps-26, rps-27, rps-16, rps-2, rps-4, rps-17, rpl-24.1, rpl-27, rpl-33, rpl-36, rpl-35, and rpl-15) with enhanced stability were comprehensively identified by using six popular normalization algorithms and RankAggreg method. Functional enrichment analysis revealed that these genes were significantly overrepresented in GO terms or KEGG pathways related to ribosomes. Validation analysis using recently published datasets revealed that the expressions of newly identified candidate reference genes were more stable than the commonly used reference genes. Based on the results, we recommended using rpl-33 and rps-26 as the optimal reference genes for microarray and rps-2 and rps-4 for RNA-sequencing data validation. More importantly, the most stable rps-23 should be a promising reference gene for both data types. This study, for the first time, successfully displays a large-scale microarray data driven genome-wide identification of stable reference genes for normalizing gene expression data and provides a potential guideline on the selection of universal internal reference genes in C. elegans, for quantitative gene expression analysis.

Identifying optimal reference genes for gene expression studies in Eurasian spruce bark beetle, Ips typographus (Coleoptera: Curculionidae: Scolytinae)

“…Other ribosomal proteins such as RPL27 and RPS7, RPL7 of S. frugiperda , were the most stable reference genes under low-temperature and high-temperature 64 . Tao et al 72 showed that RPL-33 and RPS-26 are the most stable reference genes from microarray data and RPS-2 and RPS-4 from RNA-seq of Caenorhabditis elegans out of thirteen ribosomal proteins. Moreover, RPS20 was detected as the least stably expressed gene for analyzing Plutella xylostella under different conditions 73 .…”

An Integrated Bioinformatics Approach to Identify Network-Derived Hub Genes in Starving Zebrafish

“…We used meta-analysis for integration of two DNA microarray datasets—GSE1107 and GSE112272. Meta-analysis will increase the experimental sample size and maximize the statistical power, reducing the probability of false-negative results [ 47 , 48 ]. Therefore, two microarray datasets obtained from GEO relating to starvation in liver tissues of zebrafish were selected to identify reliable hub-CST genes.…”

Fluctuations in chromatin state at regulatory loci occur spontaneously under relaxed selection and are associated with epigenetically inherited variation in C. elegans gene expression

“…show a marked propensity for significant up and down fluctuations in expression over 20 generations while no such fluctuations are seen in a set of known housekeeping genes (Tao et al, 2020) (Supp. Fig.…”