Syntopic frogs reveal different patterns of interaction with the landscape: A comparative landscape genetic study of Pelophylax nigromaculatus and Fejervarya limnocharis from central China

Abstract

Amphibians are often considered excellent environmental indicator species. Natural and man‐made landscape features are known to form effective genetic barriers to amphibian populations; however, amphibians with different characteristics may have different species–landscape interaction patterns. We conducted a comparative landscape genetic analysis of two closely related syntopic frog species from central China, Pelophylax nigromaculatus (PN) and Fejervarya limnocharis (FL). These two species differ in several key life history traits; PN has a larger body size and larger clutch size, and reaches sexual maturity later than FL. Microsatellite DNA data were collected and analyzed using conventional (F ST, isolation by distance (IBD), AMOVA) and recently developed (Bayesian assignment test, isolation by resistance) landscape genetic methods. As predicted, a higher level of population structure in FL (F ST′ = 0.401) than in PN (F ST′ = 0.354) was detected, in addition to FL displaying strong IBD patterns (r = .861) unlike PN (r = .073). A general north–south break in FL populations was detected, consistent with the IBD pattern, while PN exhibited clustering of northern‐ and southern‐most populations, suggestive of altered dispersal patterns. Species‐specific resistant landscape features were also identified, with roads and land cover the main cause of resistance to FL, and elevation the main influence on PN. These different species–landscape interactions can be explained mostly by their life history traits, revealing that closely related and ecologically similar species have different responses to the same landscape features. Comparative landscape genetic studies are important in detecting such differences and refining generalizations about amphibians in monitoring environmental changes.

Isolation by resistance analysis reveals major barrier effect imposed by the Tsinling Mountains on the Chinese wood frog

“…While our results contradict the conclusions of Zhan et al (), they are consistent with a large body of literature that has implicated mountains in the obstruction of gene flow for amphibians (e.g. Funk et al , ; Spear et al , ; Garcia, Ivy & Fu, ; Sánchez‐Montes et al , ).…”

Relative importance of isolation‐by‐environment and other determinants of gene flow in an alpine amphibian

“…2012; Garcia et al. 2017; Sandberger‐Loua et al. 2018) or with the occurrence of ridges between pairs of populations (Tallmon et al.…”

Landscape genetics reveals unique and shared effects of urbanization for two sympatric pool‐breeding amphibians

“…Landguth et al (2010) used simulations to illustrate a lag time of approximately 200 generations when using a landscape genetics approach to detect signals of barriers, although they note the magnitude of this effect likely varies with each population's effective size. The influence of lag time is also supported by empirical research that considers effects of both natural and anthropogenic features on amphibian gene flow (Garcia, Ivy, & Fu, 2017;Peterman et al, 2015;Richardson, 2012). Due to this lag, most natural features will likely have stronger signals, such as rivers appearing more important than interstate highways.…”