The reactivity of copper complexes of three different 2nd generation bispidine-based ligands (bispidine = 3,7-diazabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane; mono- and bis-tetradentate; exclusively tertiary amine donors) with dioxygen [(reversible) binding of dioxygen by copper(I)] is reported. The UV-vis, electrospray ionization mass spectra (ESI-MS), electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and vibrational spectra (resonance Raman,rR) of the dioxygen adducts indicate that, depending on the ligand and reaction conditions, several different species (mono- and dinuclear, superoxo, peroxo and hydroperoxo), partially in equilibrium with each other, are formed. Minor changes in the ligand structure and/or experimental conditions (solvent, temperature, relative concentrations) allow switching between the different forms. With one of the ligands, an end-on-peroxo-dicopper(II) and a mononuclear copper(II)-hydroperoxo complex could be characterized. With another ligand, reversible dioxygen binding was observed, leading to a meta-stable copper(II)-superoxo complex, and the amount of dioxygen involved in the reversible binding to CuI was determined quantitatively. The mechanism of dioxygen binding as well as the preference of each of the three ligands for a particular dioxygen adduct is discussed on the basis of a computational (DFT) analysis.