“…[84] In contrast, the (-)-menthone-derived oxazoline NHC-ligand 103i, designed by the Glorius group, afforded product both in excellent yield (99 %) and with excellent selectivity (96 % ee, Table 4, Entry x). [85] The NHC ligand 103j, [86] as well as the well defined Pd complex 103k (R 1 = R 2 = iPr), [87] were also extremely efficient in terms both of yield and of enantioselectivity (Table 4, Entries xi and xii). The Pd complex 103k was also useful for preparing 3-allyl-3-aryloxindoles (Table 4, Entry xiii), [88] and although the development of asymmetric routes to 3,3-disubstituted oxindoles focuses heavily on the use of 3-aryl-substituted compounds, it should be noted that use of the Pd complex 103k resulted in a 70 % ee of a 3-allyl-3-methyl-substituted oxindole (Table 4, Entry xiv).…”