Estrogen receptor α (ERα) and estrogen receptor β (ERβ) regulate different sets of gene expression, and have different ligand responses, which make the estrogen tissue-specific. Thus, the estrogen receptor (ER) subtype-selective ligands can improve the target-site selectivity and decrease the off-target effect. In order to discover the selective ER subtype ligands with novel scaffolds, in this work three-dimensional (3D) pharmacophore models of the ERα ligands (Hypo 1) and the ERβ ligands (Hypo 2) were established (correlation coefficients were 0.959 and 0.966) and validated (R 0.936 and 0.879; enrichment factors (EFs) at 2% were 16.2 and 8.4; areas under the concentration-time curve (AUC) of the receiver operating curve (ROC) were 0.88 and 0.91) using the Discovery Studio 4.0 software package. Hypo 1 and Hypo 2 were then employed for virtual screening and ten hits were found as potential candidate leads. Based on their ERα/ERβ binding affinity results by fluorescence polarization technology, two of these leads, AH-262/34334025 (AH) and AG-670/08803023 (AG) with novel scaffolds were identified as selective ERα ligands. A molecular docking study was also performed, which provided the explanation for the ER subtype preferences for AH and AG.Key words estrogen receptor ligand; pharmacophore model; virtual screening Estrogen exerts its cascade of biochemical events through estrogen receptors (ERs).1-3) Mainly, there are two ER subtypes, estrogen receptor α (ERα) and estrogen receptor β (ERβ). ERα predominates in the uterus and the mammary gland, thus being mostly responsible for the female reproductive functions, whereas ERβ plays roles in many other body compartments, such as the central nervous, urogenital and immune systems. 4,5) ERα and ERβ regulate different sets of gene expression, and have different ligand responses, which make the estrogen tissue-specific. For instance, since estrogen can promote growth in breast cancers via the activation of ERα, ERα antagonists can be used for treating breast cancer. An ERβ-selective ligand may promote ER activity in the bone without promoting tumorigenesis in the breast. Furthermore, ER subtype ligands could present opposite effect in ovarian. ERα antagonist could suppress the cell growth in ovarian cancer cell lines SKOV3 and OV2008, whereas ERβ antagonist could significantly enhance cell growth.6) Therefore, subtypeselective ligands can improve the target-site selectivity and decrease the off-target effect.Until now, many ER ligands have been reported. Most of them (such as 1, 3, 5, 8, 48 in Fig. 1) have the similar scaffold of diphenylethene or diphenylpropylene. In this work, we focused on discovering the lead compound with new scaffold. Pharmacophore model-based virtual screening is a common fast way to find the lead compounds. Therefore, pharmacophore models of the ERα and ERβ ligands were built and employed for discovering selective ER subtype ligands (Fig. 2).
ExperimentalData Preparation Sixty-nine positives with binding affinities (range from 0.3 to 7980 nmol) o...