Attempted syntheses of (smif)2Ti (smif = 1,3-di-(2-pyridyl)-2-azaallyl) based on metatheses of TiClnLm (n = 2–4) with M(smif) (M = Li, Na), in the presence of a reducing agent (Na/Hg) when necessary, failed, but several apparent Ti(II) species were identified by X-ray crystallography and multidimensional NMR spectroscopy: (smif){Li(smif-smif)}Ti (1, X-ray), [(smif)Ti]2(μ-κ3,κ3-N,N(py)2-smif,smif) (2), (smif)Ti(κ3-N,N(py)2-smif,(smif)H) (3), and (smif)Ti(dpma) (4). NMR spectroscopy and K-edge XAS showed that each compound possesses ligands that are redox non-innnocent, such that d1 Ti(III) centers AF-couple to ligand radicals: (smif){Li(smif-smif)2−}TiIII (1), [(smif2−)TiIII]2(μ-κ3,κ3-N,N(py)2-smif,smif) (2), [(smif2−)TiIII](κ3-N,N(py)2-smif,(smif)H) (3), and (smif2−)TiIII(dpma) (4). The instability of the (smif)2Ti relative to its C-C coupled dimer, 2, is rationalized via the complementary nature of the amide and smif radical anion ligands, which are also common to 3 and 4. Calculations support this contention.