We report a high-yielding solution phase synthesis of 1,3,4,6-tetraphenyl-dihydropentalene based on a simple annulation reaction of cyclopentadiene with a chalcone. Deprotonative metalation of 1,3,4,6-tetraphenyl-dihydropentalene with alkali metal bases (Li, Na, K) of moderate basicity (pK a > 15) cleanly yields the corresponding hydropentalenide complexes, which exist as solvent-separated ion pairs in coordinating solvents such as THF, pyridine, and DMSO. A second deprotonative metalation with stronger alkali metal bases (pK a > 25) yields the double-anionic, 10 π aromatic tetraphenyl-pentalenide complexes, which are of low solubility in the case of Li 2 , Na 2 , and K 2 . In the solid state the two metals are bound η 5 to each anionic ring in anti configuration as in the unsubstituted pentalenide Li 2 [C 8 H 6 ]. Mixed-metal tetraphenyl-pentalenide complexes of Li/Na/K display remarkably enhanced solubility, allowing for solution phase characterization via NMR and UV−vis spectroscopy and application in transmetalation reactions.