The
direct introduction of the valuable SCF3 moiety into organic
molecules has received considerable attention. While it can be achieved
successfully for aryl chlorides under catalysis with Ni0(cod)2 and dppf, this report investigates the Ni-catalyzed
functionalization of the seemingly more reactive aryl halides ArI
and ArBr. Counterintuitively, the observed conversion triggered by
dppf/Ni0 is ArCl > ArBr > ArI, at odds with bond
strength preferences. By a combined computational and experimental
approach, the origin of this was identified to be due to the formation
of (dppf)NiI, which favors β-F elimination as a competing
pathway over the productive cross-coupling, ultimately generating
the inactive complex (dppf)Ni(SCF2) as a catalysis dead
end. The complexes (dppf)NiI–Br and (dppf)NiI–I were isolated and resolved by X-ray crystallography.
Their formation was found to be consistent with a ligand-exchange-induced
comproportionation mechanism. In stark contrast to these phosphine-derived
Ni complexes, the corresponding nitrogen-ligand-derived species were found to be likely competent catalysts
in oxidation state I. Our computational studies of N-ligand derived
NiI complexes fully support productive NiI/NiIII catalysis, as the competing β-F elimination is disfavored.
Moreover, N-derived NiI complexes are predicted to be more
reactive than their Ni0 counterparts in catalysis. These
data showcase fundamentally different roles of NiI in carbon–heteroatom
bond formation depending on the ligand sphere.