The functional groups found among the RNA bases and in the phosphoribose backbone represent a limited repertoire from which to construct a ribozyme active site. This work investigates the possibility that simple RNA phosphodiester and hydroxyl functional groups could catalyze amide bond synthesis. Reaction of amine groups with activated esters would be catalyzed by a group that stabilizes the partial positive charge on the amine nucleophile in the transition state. 2-Amine substitutions adjacent to 3-phosphodiester or 3-hydroxyl groups react efficiently with activated esters to form 2-amide and peptide products. In contrast, analogs in which the 3-phosphodiester is replaced by an uncharged phosphotriester or is constrained in a distal conformation react at least 100-fold more slowly. Similarly, a nucleoside in which the 3-hydroxyl group is constrained trans to the 2-amine is also unreactive. Catalysis of synthetic reactions by RNA phosphodiester and ribose hydroxyl groups is likely to be even greater in the context of a preorganized and solvent-excluding catalytic center. One such group is the 2-hydroxyl of the ribosome-bound P-site adenosine substrate, which is close to the amine nucleophile in the peptidyl synthesis reaction. Given ubiquitous 2-OH groups in RNA, there exists a decisive advantage for RNA over DNA in catalyzing reactions of biological significance. N atural RNA molecules catalyze reactions at phosphodiester centers (1) and, in the case of the ribosome large subunit, form the catalytic active site for amide bond synthesis (2, 3). In vitro selection methods yield RNAs that catalyze diverse reactions, including amide bond formation (4-6). Catalysis at any RNA active site must reflect chemical limitations imposed by having four relatively similar building blocks and lacking functional groups with pKas in the physiological range.Within this set of chemical constraints, catalytic RNAs employ strategies including juxtaposition and orientation of substrates (7,8), incorporation of metal ion prosthetic groups (9, 10), perturbing the pKas of titratable base positions (11,12), and positioning 2Ј-hydroxyl groups to stabilize an oxyanion (13,14). The RNA phosphoribose backbone is also likely to play indirect roles in catalysis by functioning, for example, to position catalytic metal ions or to perturb the local environment at RNA bases.
2-Amine Acylation and Nucleotide FlexibilityA robust approach for monitoring local flexibility in RNA and DNA is based on substituting the unreactive 2Ј-hydroxyl with a more nucleophilic amine (15-17). The 2Ј-amine group serves as a chemical handle that can be selectively modified by using an activated ester. This amide-forming reaction is gated by the underlying nucleic acid structure such that 2Ј-amine substitutions at flexible nucleotides are more reactive than amine groups at constrained positions (Fig. 1A). For example, 2Ј-amine substitutions in the anticodon loop of tRNA Asp react efficiently to form the 2Ј-amide, whereas 2Ј-amine positions that form stable base pairs, ...