Symptoms Leading to a Bipolar Diagnosis: A Phone Survey of Child and Adolescent Psychiatrists

Abstract

Objective: We surveyed child and adolescent psychiatrists (CAPs) to characterize how they diagnose bipolar disorder (BPD) in children. Methods: We approached by mail and then telephone 100 CAPs randomly sampled from five regions of the main professional organization of American CAPs; 53 CAPs were reached and agreed to participate. We asked about their training and practice setting, and asked them to name 10 symptoms indicative of BPD. We conducted descriptive analyses to determine how CAPs ranked symptoms, whether reports were consistent with Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edition, Text Revision (DSM-IV-TR) criteria, and whether alternative symptom models might guide their decision making. Results: CAPs considered lability, grandiosity, family history of BPD, aggression, and expansive or euphoric mood as the most important factors in diagnosing BPD. Only 21 (39.6%) CAPs reported sufficient symptoms to meet DSM criteria for BPD (DSM-Yes status). DSM-Yes status was associated with participants' region, less expertise ( 10 years practicing child and adolescent psychiatry), and lower levels of self-reported confidence in their ability to diagnose BPD. Conclusions: CAPs vary in the symptoms they use to diagnose BPD, with most using a mixture of DSM and non-DSM symptoms. Expertise and confidence may lessen one's reliance on DSM criteria. Further studies are needed to understand CAPs' diagnostic decisions about BD and to develop interventions to support accurate diagnostic decision making and improve patient care.

Will disruptive mood dysregulation disorder reduce false diagnosis of bipolar disorder in children?

“…In the absence of information on exactly how clinicians make the diagnosis of bipolar disorder (40), we think the use of the CMRS‐P is a reasonable way to speculate about how effective DMDD would be in deflecting children with chronically explosive, irritable behavior with manic symptoms from a presumably erroneous bipolar diagnosis that they are at risk of receiving. Even if only a half or a third of children with high CMRS‐P scores received a false positive diagnosis of bipolar disorder because of their irritable, explosive and moody behavior, the likelihood is that if DMDD criteria are strictly followed, this alternative condition would not provide a better diagnostic home for the majority of children, somewhat defeating its raison d'etre.…”

National Trends in the Office-Based Treatment of Children, Adolescents, and Adults With Antipsychotics

“…11,45 Concern exists, however, over the accuracy of community diagnoses of bipolar disorder in children and adolescents. 46,47 A greater proportion of adult antipsychotic visits than child or adolescent antipsychotic visits do not include a diagnosed mental disorder. This is largely attributable to the proportionately greater role of nonpsychiatrist phy-sicians in the treatment of adults with antipsychotics than in the treatment of young people.…”

Mood swing and mood stabilizer: how specific are these terms?

“…Much confusion is caused when physicians commonly use the semiofficial concept of mood swing to identify bipolar disorders and link the term mood stabilizer to treatment with antimanic drugs. These links can lead them to overdiagnose bipolar disorders (72) and to routinely but inaccurately view the symptom of emotional/behavioral lability as a distinctive and primary bipolar manic‐type phenomenon (73).…”