Sustaining innovation in the health care workforce: A case study of community nurse consultant posts in England

Abstract

BackgroundRecruiting, retaining and meeting increasing demand for experienced, qualified nurses is an issue of concern for all health care systems. The UK has been creating clinical career structures for nurses that include innovative posts known as nurse consultants. While the numbers overall appear to have grown over the last eleven years, there is evidence that in some specialities and regions the numbers are decreasing. This paper considers the factors that sustain or curtail workforce innovations through the case example of a cohort of nurse consultants established in one community health service in England.MethodsA mixed method case study evaluation was undertaken over three years, using interviews, observations, documentary analysis and questionnaires. The final element of data collection was obtained three years later. Data was anonymised, analysed using a framework method and then integrated using a narrative synthesis.ResultsTen nurse consultant posts were created over a period of two years (2002-2004). Within two years only five posts remained and within five years (2009) only two part time posts, with the original appointees, remained. When the nurse consultants left their posts, these were not replaced. In exploring the interaction between the innovation (the nurse consultant posts), the adoptees (the senior staff in the organisation) and the context (the immediate service colleagues, the service organisation and commissioners as well as the broader NHS policy context) three key factors were identified as influential in the demise of the posts. These were: a) the extent to which there was support for individual nurses rather than the post, b) the extent to which there was an unambiguous and uncontested clinical service requirement for a nurse consultant and c) the extent to which finances for the post were judged as being used to best effect in a service setting.ConclusionsThis case study example demonstrates how tantalisingly close the nurse consultant initiative came to achieving a clinical career pathway for nurses in community services but more work was required to normalise clinician and managers' beliefs in the relevance and need for the role. Those looking to embed these types of nursing workforce innovations should pay due regard to these issues.

The contribution of Physician Assistants in primary care: a systematic review

“…The fact that the vast majority of the literature is from the USA might also be seen as an interesting finding of itself, particularly as other countries are appearing willing to at least trial the PA role without health system-specific evidence. There appears to be a progression in the reporting of new workforce roles which moves from the descriptive to single site evaluations to multi-site evaluations [83,84] and to ignore this would diminish the evidence for those considering introducing new roles. Interestingly, no dramatic changes in findings are reported in the included studies over the 40 year period or in the papers from settings outside of the USA, potentially suggesting that issues of context and method are not a complete barrier to the usefulness of the evidence presented in this review.…”

Deriving Consensus on the Characteristics of Advanced Practice Nursing

“…These include the desire to create clinical career pathway opportunities; to retain experienced nurses in direct care giving roles, rather than in administration; improve patient outcomes; improve access to care; and modernize heath systems (Drennan & Goodman, 2011;Horrocks et al, 2002;O'Baugh, Wilkes, Varughan, & O'Donohue, 2007). These include the desire to create clinical career pathway opportunities; to retain experienced nurses in direct care giving roles, rather than in administration; improve patient outcomes; improve access to care; and modernize heath systems (Drennan & Goodman, 2011;Horrocks et al, 2002;O'Baugh, Wilkes, Varughan, & O'Donohue, 2007).…”

“…It has also created difficulties in measuring the impact and efficacy of advanced practice roles. Within the context of these limitations, it is difficult to empirically ascertain the contribution of the various advanced practice roles to patient and health system outcomes (Drennan & Goodman, 2011). Variability in how the nature of advanced practice has been defined and measured adds further to this complexity.…”

Lessons From England’s Health Care Workforce Redesign: No Quick Fixes

“…6,24,25 Aligning a new role with organizational goals should also increase the sustainability of the role by, for example, ensuring that the new role is not lost when the person who first filled it leaves. 26 In sum, workforce redesign is best conceptualized not as a "skills add-on" but as a process that involves the concurrent redesign of the service and the workers' roles.…”