Sustainable Hybrid Manufacturing of AlSi5 Alloy Turbine Blade Prototype by Robotic Direct Energy Layered Deposition and Subsequent Milling: An Alternative to Selective Laser Melting?

Abstract

Additive technologies enable the flexible production through scalable layer-by-layer fabrication of simple to intricate geometries. The existing 3D-printing technologies that use powders are often slow with controlling parameters that are difficult to optimize, restricted product sizes, and are relatively expensive (in terms of feedstock and processing). This paper presents the development of an alternative approach consisting of a CAD/CAM + combined wire arc additive-manufacturing (WAAM) hybrid process utilizing the robotic MIG-based weld surfacing and milling of the AlSi5 aluminum alloy, which achieves sustainably high productivity via structural alloys. The feasibility of this hybrid approach was analyzed on a representative turbine blade piece. SprutCAM suite was utilized to identify the hybrid-manufacturing parameters and virtually simulate the processes. This research provides comprehensive experimental data on the optimization of cold metal transfer (CMT)–WAAM parameters such as the welding speed, current/voltage, wire feed rate, wall thickness, torch inclination angle (shift/tilt comparison), and deposit height. The multi-axes tool orientation and robotic milling strategies, i.e., (a) the side surface from rotational one-way bottom-up and (b) the top surface in a rectangular orientation, were tested in virtual CAM environments and then adopted during the prototype fabrication to minimize the total fabrication time. The effect of several machining parameters and robotic stiffness (during WAAM + milling) were also investigated. The mean deviation for the test piece’s tolerance between the virtual processing and experimental fabrication was −0.76 mm (approx.) at a standard deviation of 0.22 mm assessed by 3D scanning. The surface roughness definition Sa in the final WAAM pass corresponds to 36 µm, which was lowered to 14.3 µm after milling, thus demonstrating a 55% improvement through the robotic comminution. The tensile testing at 0° and 90° orientations reported fracture strengths of 159 and 161.3 MPa, respectively, while the yield stress and reduced longitudinal (0°) elongations implied marginally better toughness along the WAAM deposition axes. The process sustainability factors of hybrid production were compared with Selective Laser Melting (SLM) in terms of the part size freedom, processing costs, and fabrication time with respect to tight design tolerances. The results deduced that this alternative hybrid-processing approach enables an economically viable, resource/energy feasible, and time-efficient method for the production of complex parts in contrast to the conventional additive technologies, i.e., SLM.

Integrating Machine Learning and Mathematical Programming for Optimisation of Electric Discharge of Machining Techniques

“…The choice to use a descriptive research strategy in this investigation has been deliberate. The purpose of descriptive research is to paint a complete and accurate picture of the phenomenon being studied [16]. A descriptive research design is ideal for thoroughly investigating the current literature, mathematical models and machine learning techniques that are pertinent to EDM optimisation, given the purpose of merging these two approaches.…”

Geometry-based decomposition rules and programming strategies for complex components in additive and hybrid manufacturing

“…J. Dugar et al in [32] have explored DED process for manufacturing a simple hollow blade and studied its mechanical properties. They also did a cost analysis comparing the DED solution with PBF and standard manufacturing processes.…”

A Review on Multiplicity in Multi-Material Additive Manufacturing: Process, Capability, Scale, and Structure

“…They concluded that using HAM processes resulted in a high material yield and a better performance and flexibility than those of traditional forging methods. Dugar et al [76] used HAM, combining the WAAM in robotic machining to sustainably produce AiSi5 alloy turbine blades. They deduced that HAM enables an economically viable, resource/energy-feasible, and time-efficient production of complex parts.…”