Sustainable financial services: reflection and future perspectives

Abstract

Sustainability transformations in global financial services aimed at addressing sustainability-related risks have been long overdue and are critical for the future development of financial services. The call for sustainability transformations in financial services arose out of the Paris Agreement and the UN Sustainable Development Goal agenda. The financial services sector plays an important role in providing sustainable financial services to nudge sustainability practices among firms and consumers around the world. However, efforts for sustainability transformations among financial service providers are still slow, and little research has been documented in this area. So far, no bibliometric analysis has been conducted in this area as well. Therefore, this research undertakes a comprehensive snooping review of extant sustainable financial services research in order to establish a trend of existing financial services sustainability activities to enhance future research possibilities. Our comprehensive review of the Scopus database was guided by the PRISMA protocols, including PRISMA-P and SPAR-4-SLR. Bibliometric and content analysis approaches were also employed as analytical tools within an analytical framework. This study has also employed Microsoft Excel and the VOSviewer tool in conducting performance and science mapping analyses. After article filtering for “sustainability” was conducted, a total of 103 research documents published between 1991 and 2022 were identified as usable samples, which were critically reviewed and analyzed in this study by means of content analysis. Three major themes were investigated, including— sustainable financial products , sustainable financial services delivery , and sustainable financial services marketing strategies . Our findings show a recent growth in academic publications in the area, but also indicate relatively low financial sustainability activities around the world. This research therefore aims to provide present and future innovative insights on sustainable financial services aimed at stimulating more financial institutions, financial service managers, policy makers, and academic researchers to take more action toward greater sustainability development activities in the financial services sector.

Exploring the Evolution of Smart Cities: A Review on Energy, Mobility, and Waste Management Aspects

“…This study's methodology is based on these steps as outlined in the Scientific Procedures and Rationales for Systematic Literature Reviews (SPAR-4-SLR) protocol. Previous studies, mainly on sustainability research in general, have used this protocol [11][12][13][14].…”

The nexus of project management approaches in sustainable development: innovative behaviors as a mechanism in the Polish financial industry

“…Establishing the sustainable development concept at the project management level is of the utmost importance for successfully implementing a sustainability-oriented organizational strategy (Aarseth et al, 2017) and creating sustainable financial services (Tuyon et al, 2022). However, as Banihashemi et al (2017) stated, many companies still fail to manage projects in a sustainable way.…”

“…fintech solutions (Mention, 2019). Simultaneously, financial consumers and investors require transparency, safety and ethics embedded in their product and service offerings (Tuyon et al. , 2022).…”

ESG's Future on Sustainability Reporting: Bibliometric Analysis

“…in substance between the two methods of counting the resulting data. Meanwhile, according to (Tuyon et al, 2022), there are three main domains used in ESG, specifically the consequences of sustainability, sustainable financial services, and sustainability foundations and also argue that Sustainability Reporting is a synonym for Sustainability Development, SDGs, and CSR.…”

“…Thus, with the existence of different naming with the same purpose, the same model and framework that aims to benchmark sustainability practices related to ethics, sustainability governance, sustainability management (Tuyon et al, 2022). it is expected that in the future sustainability is not just a voluntary sustainability report, but rather a reflection of performance, policies towards sustainability innovations.…”