Surgical Outcome following Decompressive Craniectomy for Poor-Grade Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage in Patients with Associated Massive Intracerebral or Sylvian Hematomas

Abstract

Background: Patients with poor-grade aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) presenting with large intracerebral (ICH) or sylvian hematomas (SylH) have poor outcomes due to the mass effect of significant brain stem compression following mass effect. On the other hand, decompressive craniectomy (DC) can reduce morbidity and mortality in critically ill patients with massive ischemic infarction and severe head injury. However, the role of DC in SAH patients is not fully understood. We investigated the outcome of DC in poor-grade SAH presenting with large ICH or SylH. Methods: 110 consecutive patients with poor-grade SAH (Hunt & Kosnik (H&K) grades IV and V, and Fisher group 4) were admitted to our hospital between April 1, 1993, and July 30, 2004. We treated 57 of those who presented with large ICH or SylH using DC. We retrospectively reviewed medical charts, radiological findings, operative notes, and video records. Results: Among the 57 patients (mean age 57.8, male 29, female 28), 25 were classified as H&K grade IV and 32 as grade V. Ruptured aneurysms were located on the internal carotid artery in 11 and the middle cerebral artery in 46 patients. 50 of the aneurysms were small, 5 were medium, and 2 were large. Rerupture was preoperatively confirmed in 13 (22.8%). Hypothermia was applied to 17 (29.8%). The Glasgow Outcome Scale on discharge showed good recovery, moderate recovery, severe disability, vegetative state, and death in 8 (14.0%), 13 (22.8%), 16 (28.1%), 8 (14.0%), and 12 (21.1%), respectively. The outcomes of grade IV patients were favorable and poor in 14 (56.0%) and 10 (40.0%), respectively, and 1 (4.0%) died. Conclusion: Several experimental studies have also indicated that DC significantly improves outcome due to reduced intracranial pressure or increased perfusion pressure. Urgent DC for poor-grade SAH with space-occupying hematoma can lead to survival with good recovery in some patients.

Decompressive craniotomy in patients with intracranial aneurysmal hemorrhage

“…В 5 работах критерием включения в группу явля-лось наличие большой гематомы в сильвиевой щели или в височной доле мозга как фактора, приводящего к латеральной дислокации мозга и способствующего формированию ишемических очагов в бассейне сред-ней мозговой артерии [11,12,14,18,21]. В других ис-следованиях такие больные составляли отдельные под-группы [6, 13, 15-17, 20, 22, 23].…”

“…В части исследований операции по выключению аневризм из кровотока выполнялись только прямым ми-крохирургическим методом [12,16,18], в другие работы включены больные как с микрохирургическими, так и с эндоваскулярными вмешательствами [14,17,22].…”

“…и рефрактер-ной к другим видам лечения [12,[16][17][18][19]22]. Таких боль-ных делили на две группы: не имеющих очага ишемии и имеющих очаг ишемии [16,19].…”

“…Независимо от показаний к выполнению ДТЧ ряд ав-торов указывают, что чем раньше выполнена ДТЧ, тем лучше исход [17,18]. Существенные различия исходов при ранней ДТЧ у больных без ВМГ показал C. Schirmer [17] -75% благоприятных исходов при ранней деком-прессии (<48 ч) против 12,5% при поздней декомпрессии (>48 ч).…”

“…По данным N. Otani и соавт. [18], величина смещения средней линии не влияла на исход. H. Wang и соавт.…”