Surgical intensive care unit clinician estimates of the adequacy of communication regarding patient prognosis

Abstract

IntroductionIntensive care unit (ICU) patients and family members repeatedly note accurate and timely communication from health care providers to be crucial to high-quality ICU care. Practice guidelines recommend improving communication. However, few data, particularly in surgical ICUs, exist on health care provider opinions regarding whether communication is effective.MethodsTo evaluate ICU clinician perceptions regarding adequacy of communication regarding prognosis, we developed a survey and administered it to a cross section of surgical ICU nurses, surgical ICU physicians, nurse practitioners (NPs), and surgeons.ResultsSurgeons had a high satisfaction with communication regarding prognosis for themselves (90%), ICU nurses (85%), and ICU physicians and NPs (85%). ICU nurses noted high satisfaction with personal (82%) and ICU physician and NP (71%) communication, but low (2%) satisfaction with that provided by surgeons. ICU physicians and NPs noted high satisfaction with personal (74%) and ICU nurse (88%) communication, but lower (23%) satisfaction with that provided by surgeons. ICU nurses were the most likely (75%) to report speaking to patients and patient families regarding prognosis, followed by surgeons (40%), and then ICU physicians and NPs (33%). Surgeons noted many opportunities to speak to ICU nurses and ICU physicians and NPs about patient prognosis and noted that comments were often valued. ICU physicians and NPs and ICU nurses noted many opportunities to speak to each other but fewer opportunities to communicate with surgeons. ICU physicians and NPs thought that their comments were valued by ICU nurses but less valued by surgeons. ICU nurses thought that their comments were less valued by ICU physicians and NPs and surgeons.ConclusionsICU nurses, surgeons, and ICU intensivists and NPs varied widely in their satisfaction with communication relating to prognosis. Clinician groups also varied in whether they thought that they had opportunities to communicate prognosis and whether their concerns were valued by other provider groups. These results hint at the nuanced and complicated relationships present in surgical ICUs. Further validation studies and further evaluations of patient and family member perspectives are needed.

Palliative Care Professional Development for Critical Care Nurses: A Multicenter Program

“…1,2,14 Challenges to palliative care integration, as well as nurses' experiences, often vary by ICU type. 17,18,[50][51][52][53][54][55] In our initiative, the culture around nursing involvement and palliative care led to our substituting 1 ICU for another. Certainly, our experience underscores the importance of developing a shared vision of palliative care and the role of nurses and of seeking input and support from key unit stakeholders before and throughout implementation.…”

Lessons Learned from a Palliative Care-Related Communication Intervention in an Adult Surgical Intensive Care Unit

“…Evidence from our own institution both suggest that surgeons, SICU nurses, and SICU intensivists and nurse practitioners have highly varying levels of satisfaction with communication regarding prognosis [25] and highlights SICU nurse-identified barriers to communication regarding prognosis [26]. Barriers to palliative carerelated communication about prognosis include: (A) difficulty arranging meetings, (B) provider, patient, and family member discomfort with palliative care-related communication, (C) perceived lack of education surrounding palliative care-related communication skills, and (D) fear that such conversations lead to conflict between provider teams [26].…”

How Much Care Is Too Much Care?

“…[1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12] However, little academic research or analysis have focused on how the feeling that we are providing inappropriate care actually contributes to these 2 barriers that make it difficult to attract and keep the highest quality practitioners in our field.…”