Surgeon symptoms, strain, and selections: Systematic review and meta-analysis of surgical ergonomics

Abstract

BackgroundMany surgeons experience work-related pain and musculoskeletal symptoms; however, comprehensive reporting of surgeon ailments is lacking in the literature. We sought to evaluate surgeons' work-related symptoms, possible causes of these symptoms, and to report outcomes associated with those symptoms.Materials and methodsFive major medical indices were queried for articles published between 1980 and 2014. Included articles evaluated musculoskeletal symptoms and ergonomic outcomes in surgeons. A meta-analysis using a fixed-effect model was used to report pooled results.ResultsForty articles with 5152 surveyed surgeons were included. Sixty-eight percent of surgeons surveyed reported generalized pain. Site-specific pain included pain in the back (50%), neck (48%), and arm or shoulder (43%). Fatigue was reported by 71% of surgeons, numbness by 37%, and stiffness by 45%. Compared with surgeons performing open surgery, surgeons performing minimally invasive surgery (MIS) were significantly more likely to experience pain in the neck (OR 2.77 [95% CI 1.30–5.93]), arm or shoulder (OR 4.59 [2.19–9.61]), hands (OR 2.99 [1.33–6.71], and legs (OR 12.34 [5.43–28.06]) and experience higher odds of fatigue (8.09 [5.60–11.70]) and numbness (6.82 [1.75–26.65]). Operating exacerbated pain in 61% of surgeons, but only 29% sought treatment for their symptoms. We found no direct association between muscles strained and symptoms.ConclusionsMost surgeons report work-related symptoms but are unlikely to seek medical attention. MIS surgeons are significantly more likely to experience musculoskeletal symptoms than surgeons performing open surgery. Symptoms experienced do not necessarily correlate with strain.

Surgeons' posture and muscle strain during laparoscopic and robotic surgery

“…It takes many years of education to become skilled in advanced surgical procedures, and maintaining surgeon safety should be a priority. There is a high prevalence (20–100 per cent) of musculoskeletal pain among surgeons which may affect multiple sites. In addition to having putative benefits for the patient, robotic‐assisted laparoscopic surgery (RALS) is thought to be less physically demanding for the surgeon than conventional laparoscopy (LAP).…”

Ergonomic hazards in otolaryngology

“…Surgeons report a high prevalence of shoulder, neck, and back discomfort and pain . Overexertion and overuse are the most common causes of injury to surgeons and the leading reasons for missed workdays .…”

“…4 Surgeons report a high prevalence of shoulder, neck, and back discomfort and pain. 5 Overexertion and overuse are the most common causes of injury to surgeons and the leading reasons for missed workdays. 6,7 As reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, in 2011, nearly half of missed workdays resulting from work-related injuries were attributed to overexertion or body motion-related events, with an average cost of $22,300 from lost productivity.…”

Head‐up display assisted endoscopic lumbar discectomy—A technical note

“…As in the interventional radiology and cardiology literature, optimal ergonomics are increasingly being recognized as a contributing factor to long surgical careers, particularly among minimally invasive surgeons . In a recent meta‐analysis of surgical ergonomics it was found that MIS surgeons are significantly more likely to experience neck pain, shoulder pain, and generalized fatigue compared to surgeons performing open procedures . The static and often awkward postures necessary for MIS, including viewing a monitor not in line with the operative field contribute to this significantly.…”