Supporting shared decision making for older people with multiple health and social care needs: a realist synthesis

Abstract

BackgroundHealth care systems are increasingly moving towards more integrated approaches. Shared decision making (SDM) is central to these models but may be complicated by the need to negotiate and communicate decisions between multiple providers, as well as patients and their family carers; particularly for older people with complex needs. The aim of this review was to provide a context relevant understanding of how interventions to facilitate SDM might work for older people with multiple health and care needs, and how they might be applied in integrated care models.MethodsIterative, stakeholder driven, realist synthesis following RAMESES publication standards. It involved: 1) scoping literature and stakeholder interviews (n = 13) to develop initial programme theory/ies, 2) systematic searches for evidence to test and develop the theories, and 3) validation of programme theory/ies with stakeholders (n = 11). We searched PubMed, The Cochrane Library, Scopus, Google, Google Scholar, and undertook lateral searches. All types of evidence were included.ResultsWe included 88 papers; 29 focused on older people or people with complex needs. We identified four context-mechanism-outcome configurations that together provide an account of what needs to be in place for SDM to work for older people with complex needs. This includes: understanding and assessing patient and carer values and capacity to access and use care, organising systems to support and prioritise SDM, supporting and preparing patients and family carers to engage in SDM and a person-centred culture of which SDM is a part. Programmes likely to be successful in promoting SDM are those that allow older people to feel that they are respected and understood, and that engender confidence to engage in SDM.ConclusionsTo embed SDM in practice requires a radical shift from a biomedical focus to a more person-centred ethos. Service providers will need support to change their professional behaviour and to better organise and deliver services. Face to face interactions, permission and space to discuss options, and continuity of patient-professional relationships are key in supporting older people with complex needs to engage in SDM. Future research needs to focus on inter-professional approaches to SDM and how families and carers are involved.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s12877-018-0853-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

How do health and social care professionals in England and Wales assess mental capacity? A literature review

“…Failure to offer this support or make adjustments is discriminatory against people with disabilities and people from different cultural, ethnic and religious backgrounds, whose approach to decision-making may be influenced by particular value systems and ethical frameworks [58]. When people are not enabled to participate meaningfully in decisions about their care, their satisfaction in services and adherence to treatment regimes are reduced and their carers' quality of life and mood are adversely affected [59]. Care providers could face legal challenges by service users and their families and potential financial penalties, if their mental capacity assessments are judged to be inadequate.…”

Relational aspects of mastery for frail, older adults: The role of informal caregivers in the care process

“…Care is the result of a relationship between two or more persons where all parties need to be involved (Holroyd-Leduc et al, 2016;Lloyd, Galnan, Cameron, Seymour, & Smith, 2014). When creating a basis for care, there is a need to move towards a relationship-centred care where interrelationships between caregivers and care recipients, and the importance of interpersonal interactions is taken into account (Bunn et al, 2018;Dewar & Nolan, 2013;Fjordside & Morville, 2016). Having respectful and attentive carers is one aspect of good care; namely, carers who respect the preferences and wishes of older adults, treat them as capable persons, and support and simulate them to make their own choices (José et al, 2016).…”

Engaging older adults in self-management talk in healthcare encounters: a systematic review protocol

“…Healthcare delivery must be transformed to address the challenges of promoting shared decision-making with older adults with complex care needs [7,8]. This entails a shift from disease-specific to patient-centred models of care [9].…”

“…How best to support shared decision-making for older adults living with multiple health and social care needs is an emerging focus of healthcare research, education, and policy [7,10,17]. A review of the communication practices involved in healthcare decision-making as it relates to self-management can help identify effective and potentially trainable strategies to improve older adults' participation in decisions relevant to their health and care.…”