Supporting crime detection and operational planning with soft systems methodology and viable systems model

Abstract

In recent years the introduction and subsequent enhancements of information technology has seen the emergence of major opportunities for developing new approaches to improve information interchange. The provision of information provides opportunities to find resolutions to problem situations, and the power of providing relevant and accurate information through using information systems cannot be underestimated. However, the world of information systems thinking has, so far, experienced difficulty finding a methodology suitable for utilizing the full range of available current information technology. This situation in the real world shows itself predominantly as information starvation as current information systems struggle to bring order and structure to information technology developments. This paper will discuss the issues relating to the development of a new generic framework. The novel aspect of this generic framework for planning information systems is that it integrates Soft Systems Methodology (SSM) and Viable Systems Model (VSM) in a coherent whole, whilst embracing the concepts of self-adaptation and autonomy. Further, the generic framework integrates the spatial analysis capabilities of a Geographical Information System (GIS). The generic framework will then be tested in real-world problem situations in order to test its effectiveness, efficiency and efficacy with regards to finding suitable solutions to the problem of information starvation. The importance of focusing the framework on GIS functionality is related to the fact that in many organizations GIS is employed as the solution to information starvation because of its ability to display spatial information. This paper will demonstrate the implementation of the generic framework in a UK Police Authority, a large emergency service that suffers from information starvation. In the context of a UK Police Authority the combination of SSM and VSM being supported by GIS functionality is seen as being a significant progression in relation to crime detection and operational planning.

A Multi-Methodological Approach to Complex Problem Solving: The Case of Serbian Enterprise

“…In that case, there are the following possibilities: firstly, employment of systems methodologies within the System of Systems Methodologies [18] that implies using one systems methodology as a dominant and another methodology as a supportive or within Total Systems Intervention in which different methodologies may be used within the same intervention to deal with different aspects of the problem situation (e.g., [19]). Then, one complete systems methodology can be combined with the parts of another methodology (for example, using the Viable System Model or System Dynamics' causal loop diagrams within Soft Systems Methodology) (e.g., [20]). Finally, the most complex situation is the one in which the parts of methodologies from different paradigms are used together within particular problem situations-for example, cognitive maps with System Dynamics' models (e.g., [21]) or rich pictures, root definitions and conceptual models as the key methodological tools of SSM with System Dynamics' causal loop diagrams and stock and flow diagrams (e.g., [22]).…”

The Challenge of Integrating OHS into Industrial Project Risk Management: Proposal of a Methodological Approach to Guide Future Research (Case of Mining Projects in Quebec, Canada)

“…Soft systems methodology is an approach composed of seven steps [41][42][43]. These steps rely on the human activity systems concept in order to define the challenge and propose changes or transformations ( Figure 9): Figure 9.…”

An Integrated Artificial Neural Network and System Dynamics Approach in Support of the Viable System Model to Enhance Industrial Intelligence: The Case of a Large Broiler Industry

“…Complementary methods/methodologies Schwaninger, 2000 Team syntegrity Schwaninger, 2004b System dynamics Ríos, 2006 System dynamics and team syntegrity Kinloch et al, 2009 Soft systems methodology Donaires et al, 2010 Team syntegrity Jones et al, 2007 Agent-based simulation Azadeh and Darivandi, 2010 Discreet-event simulation Darivandi Shoushtari et al, 2011/ Darivandi Shoushtari, 2013 SCOR model and democratic hierarchy Figure 3 shows the methodology and the output of each step.…”