Support Requirements for Cognitive Readiness in Complex Operations

Abstract

The authors report two experiments studying the requirements for effective decision making in a complex environment. The focus lies on three components of individual cognitive readiness: situation awareness (SA), problem solving, and decision making. Participants performed a simulated society management task in which they could allocate resources to stabilize a national crisis involving multiple interrelated factors (political, economic, environmental, and social). A striking aspect of this simulation is that even though information about the causes and effects within the system is available, most individuals fail to bring the system to the targeted state because of unintended consequences of their decisions. The experiments test the impact of two cognitive support tools designed to improve anticipation of future outcomes. Results show that supporting short-term anticipation (with perfectly accurate projections) was insufficient to improve effectiveness, but supporting longterm anticipation (with approximate projections) successfully improved performance in this complex environment. We conclude with a review of requirements that training and technological support should address to augment individual cognitive readiness for operations in complex environments and propose an extension to SA theory by conceptualizing a Level 4 SA (long-term projection) that may be particularly important to overcome the "wall of complexity. "

A cognitive prosthesis for complex decision-making

“…While a variety of analytical tools have been designed to support understanding and planning in complex domains (e.g., Allen, Corpac, and Frisbie, 2006;Chappell et al, 2004;Chen and Lee, 2003;Langton and Das, 2007;Surdu and Kitka, 2008;Vester, 2007), the effectiveness of such tools is not often investigated in a systematic manner using the experimental research method (e.g., Lafond et al, 2012;Lerch and Harter, 2001).…”

Cognitive Ergonomics: Supporting Effective Use of Predictive Analytics Using Ethical Mental Frameworks

“…As has been shown in the research of Lafond, DuCharme, Gagnon, and Tremblay (2012), heavy reliance on predictive modeling can, under certain conditions, improve the accuracy of our decision‐making. However, these gains are also accompanied by an unintended side effect: the impairment of professional decision‐making capacities.…”

What Affects Human Decision Making in Human–Robot Collaboration?: A Scoping Review

“…In complex operations, cognitive readiness, which includes situation awareness, problem-solving, and decision making, is essential for effective resource allocation. In addition, supporting long-term anticipation in decision making can significantly improve performance in complex environments, and cognitive support tools can enhance the anticipation of future outcomes [34].…”