Supervision of local government in Zimbabwe: The travails of mayors

Abstract

The discourse on decentralisation theoretically supports central government supervision of local government. The exercise of such powers by the central government of Zimbabwe is mired in controversy. Mayors are often suspended and/or dismissed to safeguard so-called "public interests". In particular, those who are from the opposition political party, the Movement for Democratic Change, have been greatly affected in this regard. The supervisory interventions of the Zimbabwe African National Unity-Patriotic Front led national (central) government have raised questions about the very existence of local democracy and the parameters within which supervision should be implemented. The inadequacy of the laws regulating central supervision over local government and, in some cases, the blatant disregard of such laws by the supervising authority have left mayors vulnerable to arbitrary suspensions and/or dismissal. Such interventions have been motivated mainly by sinister political objectives rather than a genuine desire to improve local governance. A case study methodology focusing on the supervision of mayors in Zimbabwe since independence has been adopted. Keywords: Local government, local autonomy, mayors, supervision, power politics, decentralisation, Zimbabwe

An exploratory study on the challenges faced by South African municipalities in implementing the Municipal Standard Chart of Accounts: a case of the city of Tshwane

“…Non-credible information from municipalities made it difficult for the National Treasury to conduct deeper data analysis and sector comparisons to improve financial performance (Chigwata, Murumahoko & Madhekeni, 2019). Moreover, the misalignment in the IDP and the capital and operating expenditures were the result of a failure to drive expenditure from a project perspective (National Treasury, 2014).…”

“…There have been more efforts to regulate local government with the intention of modernising financial management. Among the interventions was the Back-to-Basics program introduced in 2014, which aimed at turning around South African municipalities but did not achieve the intended results (Chigwata et al, 2019). Others include the Municipal Supply Chain Management Regulations, Financial Misconduct Procedure, and Criminal Proceedings, which have not yielded positive results considering the audit outcomes.…”

Central-Local Relations in Zimbabwe

“…The minister's powers are often characterised as extensive, intrusive and invasive, prompting calls for role clarity, dichotomy and more autonomy for local government (Marumahoko & Fessha, 2011). Among others, the minister can give policy direction, rescind and reverse council resolutions (Chigwata, Marumahoko & Madhekeni, 2019)…”

Decentralisation and Central Government Control: Experiences from the Local Government Reform in Zimbabwe

“…Supervisory powers were abused by the ZANU-PFdominated central government to control local governments through the back door. This resulted in numerous suspensions and dismissals of democratically elected mayors (Chigwata et al, 2019). In essence, in Zimbabwe's vertically divided authority context, the suspension of mayors in major cities has been weaponised to frustrate and hinder the extent to which local governments can democratically govern autonomously.…”