The scale-up of zeolite catalysts from powder to industrially relevant shapes is widely neglected in fundamental research because of the added preparative and analytical complexity. Binders incorporated to improve mechanical stability and related structuring steps can cause decisive performance alterations, which are currently difficult to predict. Here, by characterizing physical, extruded, and milled admixtures of MFI zeolites with common silica, alumina, or clay binders, we elucidate the cause and magnitude of property variations induced by shaping. Subsequent evaluation in the conversion of methanol to hydrocarbons confirms the corresponding catalytic impacts. Our findings show that binder effects can, without optimization, match or even exceed those of hierarchically structuring the porosity of the MFI crystals. The macroporosity and related mass transfer properties of the technical bodies are enhanced on extrusion with attapulgite and kaolin as a result of their larger particle size. Comparatively, the acid site density and speciation is binderdependent. Although a decreased Brønsted acidity, due to the partial dealumination or ion exchange of the zeolite framework, reduces the intrinsic activity of the catalysts, no direct correlation is observed with the selectivity or catalyst lifetime. The unique role of attapulgite in promoting the longevity and light-olefin selectivity of the zeolite is correlated with the reversible neutralization of the framework by mobile Mg species. Ball-milling proves a complementary tool to rapidly screen for potential reactions between component phases with small sample quantities. An improved understanding of the complex morphological and chemical interactions within zeolite−binder composites and of how they can be effectively tuned will ultimately accelerate the development of superior catalytic technologies.