The critical use of superhard materials in modern industry ranges from polishing and cutting tools to wear-resistant coatings. This emphasizes one of the most challenging problems in materials science, especially in the field of superhard materials, which is the accurate characterization of a material's mechanical and elastic properties. Recently, Qin et al. synthesized ReB 2 compacts under high pressure/high temperature (HPHT) conditions and measured the elastic constants via an ultrasonic method.[1] They reported values for the Vickers hardness and elastic moduli well below the previously published theoretical and experimental data and therefore claim that ReB 2 does not belong in the class of superhard materials. [2][3][4][5] Due to existing doubts regarding the mechanical robustness of ReB 2 we have synthesized powder compacts of ReB 2 by spark plasma sintering (Fig. 1) to perform independent studies of the elastic moduli. [6] The present study will demonstrate that the shear modulus, which is an excellent predictor of hardness, [7,8] of the recovered polycrystalline sample, is significantly higher than the value reported by Qin et al. Surface Brillouin spectroscopy (SBS), an experimental technique that is based on the inelastic scattering of light, is utilized in this study. Additionally, some of the more subtle differences between the work performed by Qin et al. and ours will be discussed in an effort to elucidate the origin of the drastically different results reported by each group.The nondestructive characterization of materials by SBS has been successfully used to constrain the elastic parameters of a broad range of systems from polymers to superhard materials. [9,10] The details of the experimental setup, the principles of how this works, and the technical characteristics can be found elsewhere.[11] Briefly, a diode pumped laser (Coherent Verdi-2) with l ¼ 532.1 nm wavelength light was focused on the sample surface and a six-pass tandem Fabry-Perot interferometer (Sandercock model) was used for the spectral measurements. The Brillouin spectra were measured in back-scattering geometry.Typical Brillouin spectra of a compacted ReB 2 pellet are shown in Figure 2. The strongest symmetric peaks are related to inelastic scattering of photons on surface acoustic Rayleigh wave phonons and provide the Rayleigh wave velocity (V RW ) through the relation:where n is the Brillouin shift associated with the peak position of the strongest symmetric peaks, and u is the scattering angle. Equation 1 can also be used to estimate the longitudinal sound velocity (V L ) in the sample using the weaker Brillouin peaks (at higher frequencies, Fig. 2) that result from the propagation of the longitudinal lateral leaky wave in the bulk material.[12] Each spectrum, which consists of the sum of individual spectra that were collected for approximately one hour, was accumulated over 10 and 20 hours in total to improve the very low signal-to-noise ratio of the Brillouin peaks associated with the longitudinal lateral leaky wave in indi...