1H‐DOSY‐Spektren von Liganden für hochenantioselektive Reaktionen – eine schnelle und einfache Methode zur Optimierung katalytischer Reaktionsbedingungen
Abstract:DOSY für die Katalyse: Bei ausgewählten Phosphoramiditen und ihren Übergangsmetallkomplexen gilt, dass für Liganden, deren Komplexe hochenantioselektive Reaktionen katalysieren, ein DOSY‐NMR‐spektroskopisches Screening der freien Liganden die Vorhersage des Verlaufs der Aggregation ihrer Komplexe ermöglicht (siehe Bild). Da diese Methode keine Kenntnis der Komplexstruktur erfordert, ist sie sehr nützlich für Optimierungsprozesse.
“…For extended interaction areas, however, unex-pectedly high interaction energies have been calculated, [22] unusual C À C bonds are stabilized with the help of a multitude of dispersion interactions, [23] and the concept of "dispersion energy donors" has been developed. [24] Recent studies by our research group on the aggregation behavior of phosphoramidite ligands 1-3 as well as of their transition metal complexes (M = Cu, Ir, Pd) proved the general tendency of these ligands to form intermolecular interactions [25] based on p-p as well as CH-p interactions, in accordance with the results of Pregosin. [17] The intriguing and surprising result of our studies was that the aggregation trends of the highly enantioselective ligands 1 and 2 are almost independent of the transition metal used and/or the structure of the complex.…”
Section: Introductionsupporting
confidence: 73%
“…Despite the vast structural knowledge about phosphor-A C H T U N G T R E N N U N G amidite Cu complexes acquired by our research group, [25,27] copper was not the metal of choice for the investigation of ligand-ligand interactions because ligand-exchange processes within Cu complexes are too fast on the NMR time scale for detailed structural investigations. Furthermore, basic structural knowledge about the Pd complexes was already available from aggregation studies.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Both the 31 P and 1 H signals of these different trans complexes show severe spectral overlap and, in addition, aggregation phenomena at low temperature, rotational processes, and conformational exchange cause a significant broadening of the 1 H signals, which additionally impairs signal resolution. [25] Nevertheless, some important structural information concerning these complex species could be gained. As no release of ligand was observed with decreasing temperature, a temperature-dependent interconversion into other complex species, as we observed for phosphoramidite copper complexes, [27b] could be excluded.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…[17] The intriguing and surprising result of our studies was that the aggregation trends of the highly enantioselective ligands 1 and 2 are almost independent of the transition metal used and/or the structure of the complex. [25] This suggests a general interaction pattern of phosphoramidites beyond single and structure-dependent p-p or CH-p interactions.…”
During the last decade, phosphoramidites have been established as a so-called privileged class of ligands in various transition metal catalyses. However, the interactions responsible for their favorable properties have hitherto remained elusive. To address this issue, the formation trends, structural features, and interligand interaction patterns of several trans- and cis-[PdLL'Cl2] complexes have been investigated by NMR spectroscopy. The energetic contribution of their interligand interactions has been measured experimentally using the supramolecular balance for transition-metal complexes. The resulting energetics combined with an analysis of the electrostatic potential surfaces reveal that in phosphoramidites not only the aryl groups but the complete (CH)CH3 Ph moieties of the amine side chains form extended quasi-planar CH-π and π-π interaction surfaces. Application of the supramolecular balance has shown that modulations in these extended interaction surfaces cause energetic differences that are relevant to enantioselective catalysis. In addition, the energetics of these interligand interactions are quite independent of the actual structures of the complexes. This is shown by similar formation and aggregation trends of complexes with the same ligand but different structures. The extended quasi-planar electrostatic interaction surface of the (CH)CH3 Ph moiety explains the known pattern of successful ligand modulation and the substrate specificity of phosphoramidites. Thus, we propose modulations in these extended CH-π and π-π interaction areas as a refined stereoselection mode for these ligands. Based on the example of phosphoramidites, this study reveals three general features potentially applicable to various ligands in asymmetric catalysis. First, specific combinations of alkyl and aryl moieties can be used to create extended anisotropic interaction areas. Second, modulations in these interaction surfaces cause energetic differences that are relevant to catalytic applications. Third, bulky substituents with matching complementary interaction surfaces should not only be considered in terms of steric hindrance but also in terms of attractive and repulsive interactions, a feature that may often be underestimated in asymmetric catalysis.
“…For extended interaction areas, however, unex-pectedly high interaction energies have been calculated, [22] unusual C À C bonds are stabilized with the help of a multitude of dispersion interactions, [23] and the concept of "dispersion energy donors" has been developed. [24] Recent studies by our research group on the aggregation behavior of phosphoramidite ligands 1-3 as well as of their transition metal complexes (M = Cu, Ir, Pd) proved the general tendency of these ligands to form intermolecular interactions [25] based on p-p as well as CH-p interactions, in accordance with the results of Pregosin. [17] The intriguing and surprising result of our studies was that the aggregation trends of the highly enantioselective ligands 1 and 2 are almost independent of the transition metal used and/or the structure of the complex.…”
Section: Introductionsupporting
confidence: 73%
“…Despite the vast structural knowledge about phosphor-A C H T U N G T R E N N U N G amidite Cu complexes acquired by our research group, [25,27] copper was not the metal of choice for the investigation of ligand-ligand interactions because ligand-exchange processes within Cu complexes are too fast on the NMR time scale for detailed structural investigations. Furthermore, basic structural knowledge about the Pd complexes was already available from aggregation studies.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Both the 31 P and 1 H signals of these different trans complexes show severe spectral overlap and, in addition, aggregation phenomena at low temperature, rotational processes, and conformational exchange cause a significant broadening of the 1 H signals, which additionally impairs signal resolution. [25] Nevertheless, some important structural information concerning these complex species could be gained. As no release of ligand was observed with decreasing temperature, a temperature-dependent interconversion into other complex species, as we observed for phosphoramidite copper complexes, [27b] could be excluded.…”
Section: Resultsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…[17] The intriguing and surprising result of our studies was that the aggregation trends of the highly enantioselective ligands 1 and 2 are almost independent of the transition metal used and/or the structure of the complex. [25] This suggests a general interaction pattern of phosphoramidites beyond single and structure-dependent p-p or CH-p interactions.…”
During the last decade, phosphoramidites have been established as a so-called privileged class of ligands in various transition metal catalyses. However, the interactions responsible for their favorable properties have hitherto remained elusive. To address this issue, the formation trends, structural features, and interligand interaction patterns of several trans- and cis-[PdLL'Cl2] complexes have been investigated by NMR spectroscopy. The energetic contribution of their interligand interactions has been measured experimentally using the supramolecular balance for transition-metal complexes. The resulting energetics combined with an analysis of the electrostatic potential surfaces reveal that in phosphoramidites not only the aryl groups but the complete (CH)CH3 Ph moieties of the amine side chains form extended quasi-planar CH-π and π-π interaction surfaces. Application of the supramolecular balance has shown that modulations in these extended interaction surfaces cause energetic differences that are relevant to enantioselective catalysis. In addition, the energetics of these interligand interactions are quite independent of the actual structures of the complexes. This is shown by similar formation and aggregation trends of complexes with the same ligand but different structures. The extended quasi-planar electrostatic interaction surface of the (CH)CH3 Ph moiety explains the known pattern of successful ligand modulation and the substrate specificity of phosphoramidites. Thus, we propose modulations in these extended CH-π and π-π interaction areas as a refined stereoselection mode for these ligands. Based on the example of phosphoramidites, this study reveals three general features potentially applicable to various ligands in asymmetric catalysis. First, specific combinations of alkyl and aryl moieties can be used to create extended anisotropic interaction areas. Second, modulations in these interaction surfaces cause energetic differences that are relevant to catalytic applications. Third, bulky substituents with matching complementary interaction surfaces should not only be considered in terms of steric hindrance but also in terms of attractive and repulsive interactions, a feature that may often be underestimated in asymmetric catalysis.
“…This method was tested on Pd II complexes using combinations of the well-known phosphoramidite ligands (S a ,R c ,R c )-1, [7] (S c ,S c )-2*, and (R c ,R c )-2 [8] (see Figure 2 b), which find broad application in many asymmetric catalytic reactions. [7][8][9] Moreover, we could already observe a general affinity of these phosphoramidites to form noncovalent interligand interactions in Cu complexes [10] and in aggregation studies of these ligands and their Cu, Pd, and Ir complexes. [11] In these three ligands, all heteroatoms encompassing the dipoles are located in a very small and structurally rigid inner sphere (O 2 PN moieties, see Figure 2 b).…”
For some decades bidentate ligands have prevailed in the field of transition-metal catalysis. [1] The superiority of bidentate ligands over monodentates was explained by the higher conformational rigidity of the ligands and their stronger coordination to the metal. [1b] However, in the last few years monodentate ligands have experienced a revival, and moreover interest in rational ligand design has grown tremendously: [2] Monodentate ligands have been developed which are able to self-assemble in the coordination sphere of the metal center through weak ligand-ligand interactions, such as hydrogen bonding [2d-g] and metal-bridged coordinative bonding. [2h-j] However, the use of weak interligand interactions based on CH-p and p-p interactions for rational ligand design is still very challenging. [2a] Various experimental and theoretical approaches have been devised to investigate and quantify noncovalent interactions such as hydrogen bonding and p-p stacking and their dependency on solvent properties. [3] The "double-mutant cycles" developed by Fersht et al. have become a powerful thermodynamic tool for the experimental quantification of single noncovalent interactions in proteins and in host-guest model systems. [4] In addition the "molecular torsion balance" developed by Wilcox and co-workers [5] has been applied to quantify CH-p interactions and aromatic interactions in organic molecules. [3a,b] However, no method has been presented to measure the contribution of noncovalent ligandligand interactions within transition-metal complexes to date. For guest-host systems binding constants are typically used for the quantification of noncovalent interactions. However, in the case of metal complexes the binding constant reflects not only noncovalent interactions, but primarily metal-ligand binding based on electronic properties such as the s-donor/pacceptor properties of the ligands. Therefore, for the measurement of pure ligand-ligand interactions, covalent and noncovalent contributions to the binding constant must be separated. In addition, possible changes in the electronic and electrostatic properties must be considered, that is, changes in the stereoelectronic properties of the metal-ligand bond and of the electrostatic contributions of the dipoles due to reorientation within the ligands upon cis-trans isomerization. To the best of our knowledge, it was previously not possible to separate and quantify the contributions of noncovalent interactions (e.g. CH-p and p-p interactions) from stereoelectronic properties and electrostatic interactions in transition-metal complexes.In this study we present the first method for the quantification of noncovalent ligand-ligand interactions in transition-metal complexes separated from stereoelectronic and electrostatic effects. Based on the formation trends of different phosphoramidite palladium complexes the free energy difference DDG caused by the formation of additional attractive CH-p interactions was determined. Moreover, 1 H 1 H NOESY measurements and 1 H chemical shi...
Die Kraft der Enantiomere: Eine universelle Methode zur Messung nichtkovalenter Wechselwirkungen in Übergangsmetallen wird präsentiert, die diese von elektronischen Effekten separiert. An Pd‐Komplexen mit zwei enantiomeren und einem enantiomerenreinen Phosphoramiditliganden wird experimentell gezeigt, dass Modulationen in ausgedehnten CH‐π‐ und π‐π Wechselwirkungsflächen ΔG‐Änderungen bewirken, die für die Stereoselektion relevant sind.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.