Suicide behaviour and arsenic levels in drinking water: a possible association?

Abstract

BackgroundA considerable part of the global population is exposed to arsenic-contaminated drinking water which is the main source of inorganic arsenic(As) exposure in humans. Arsenic exposure interferes with the action of enzymes, essential cations, and transcriptional events in cells throughout the body, and a multitude of multisystemic non-cancer effects might ensue. The aim of our review was to evaluate the effects of arsenic contamination in drinking water on suicides rates.MethodsA systematic literature search (English written literature) was conducted in electronic databases MEDLINE, SCOPUS. Evidences dating from 1999 till 2016 have been collected. A manual search of reference lists of included studies and review articles was successively performed. All references of the retrieved studies were also reviewed to avoid missing relevant publications.The key search terms included: “arsenic AND water AND suicide”.ResultsThe literature search yielded 13 publications, but we identified 2 manuscripts available for this systematic review. The 2 studies included in the review, were published in 2015 and in 2017 and settled in Italy and Hungary. The levels of arsenic in the waters ranged from 0.016 μg/l to >50 μg/l. The findings of the two studies are conflicting, in fact Pompili et al. reported an apparently beneficial effect of arsenic on suicides rates, with an inverse correlation of arsenic concentration and local suicide rates, in contrast to a positive correlation with natural-cause mortality rates.ConclusionsOur review led to conflicting results, so the diatribe about the real effects of arsenic intake of suicidal behaviors is still open. Therefore, we encourage other colleagues to conduct further studies in other locations in order to have more reliable results.

Wood-based biochar for the removal of potentially toxic elements in water and wastewater: a critical review

“…Geogenically, some PTEs, in particular As, may be released into groundwater, which occurs from weathering processes, geothermal water, and vulcanisation [72][73][74]. Geogenic sources contribute to the contamination of groundwater with PTEs; this groundwater is used as drinking water in many countries, thus posing a health risk to millions of people worldwide [75][76][77][78][79][80][81][82][83][84]. Anthropogenically, the industrial, municipal, and farm wastewaters are the main sources of PTE-contaminated water [17,70,71].…”

The Ameliorative Effect of Green Tea, Garlic and Vitamin C on Arsenic Toxicity in Male Mice: Biochemical and Histological Forensic Perspectives

“…In fish and seaweed, arsenic is found in the form of arsenolipids and could be added to hot tea or food to kill people [3]. It can also be used in suicides [4]. The metal is commonly found as trivalent arsenite and pentavalent arsenate.…”

Ameliorative Effect of Natural and Synthetic Antioxidants on Arsenic Toxicity in Male Mice: Biochemical and Histological Perspectives

“…The main source of arsenic toxicity is the drinking water contaminated with an inorganic form [2]. In fish and seaweed arsenic is found in the form of arsenolipids and could be added to hot tea or food to dispatch victims [3] and people used it in suicides [4]. The metal commonly found in two oxidation states trivalent arsenite and pentavalent arsenate.…”