Successful Postgraduate Placement Experiences: What is the Influence of Job and Supervisor Characteristics?

Abstract

We know little about what determines an effective placement experience, yet vocational placements are an integral part of many professional degree programmes. The aim of this research was to examine the influence of job (task variety, task identity, task significance, feedback, and autonomy) and supervisor (relationship quality and mentoring) characteristics on placement outcomes. The findings were tested on samples from two professions for which placement were a compulsory part of their course. Sample 1 consisted of 266 undergraduate nurses, and sample 2 consisted of 176 postgraduate psychologists. The findings showed that job and supervisor characteristics explained unique variance in professional development and placement satisfaction. Of the five job characteristics examined, skill variety, feedback from the job, and task significance influenced placement outcomes. Mentoring emerged as the most important supervisor characteristic that was associated with professional development and placement satisfaction, and to a slightly less extent, supervisor-student relationship quality was also important. The research and practical implications of the findings were discussed.

A qualitative investigation of Australian psychologists' perceptions about complementary and alternative medicine for use in clinical practice

“…Moreover, supervisors' orientation exerts an influence on trainees' preferred orientation, even years after qualifying (Carless et al, 2012). Findings are also consistent with social information processing theory, which claims that social cues from supervisors play a key role in influencing students' professional development and attitudes (Carless et al, 2012).…”

“…Some psychologists reported disappointment about the lack of CAM training or guidance on integrating CAM in psychological practice, which may be due to the predominant lack in standards and information available among education and training institutions (Bensoussan et al, 2005). It further suggests that educational experiences have a strong contribution to preferences for therapeutic orientation and interventions for psychologists (Carless, Robertson, Willy, Hart, & Chea, 2012).…”

Satisfaction with psychology training in the Veterans Healthcare Administration.

“…Indeed, those who were highly satisfied with clinical faculty were nearly three times more likely to consider the training experience again. This result is consistent with previous research demonstrating that supervisor mentoring and the quality of trainee and supervisor relationship are the most important supervisor characteristics associated with perceptions of professional development and satisfaction with training rotation for a sample of nurses (Carless, Robertson, Willy, Hart, & Chea, 2012). Further, previous research has demonstrated that negative interactions with role models serve as a detractor from choosing a career path in that role model’s field (Mutha, Takayama, & O’Neil, 1997).…”

Enablers and barriers to effective clinical supervision in the workplace: a rapid evidence review

“…There was often an expectation that supervisors had the time to develop relationships and would take the time to complete the necessary paperwork prior to and following supervision, which could be time-consuming. 80 A lack of adequate resources could lead to an overstretched workforce not being able to support each other effectively, and a decline in clinical supervision due to pressures on staff time. 18 Kenny and Allenby 60 Open access lack of monetary incentives for supervision, affecting how supervision was perceived and whether it was provided or attended.…”