Subtyping CKD Patients by Consensus Clustering: The Chronic Renal Insufficiency Cohort (CRIC) Study

Abstract

BackgroundCKD is a heterogeneous condition with multiple underlying causes, risk factors, and outcomes. Subtyping CKD with multidimensional patient data holds the key to precision medicine. Consensus clustering may reveal CKD subgroups with different risk profiles of adverse outcomes.MethodsWe used unsupervised consensus clustering on 72 baseline characteristics among 2696 participants in the prospective Chronic Renal Insufficiency Cohort (CRIC) study to identify novel CKD subgroups that best represent the data pattern. Calculation of the standardized difference of each parameter used the cutoff of ±0.3 to show subgroup features. CKD subgroup associations were examined with the clinical end points of kidney failure, the composite outcome of cardiovascular diseases, and death.ResultsThe algorithm revealed three unique CKD subgroups that best represented patients’ baseline characteristics. Patients with relatively favorable levels of bone density and cardiac and kidney function markers, with lower prevalence of diabetes and obesity, and who used fewer medications formed cluster 1 (n=1203). Patients with higher prevalence of diabetes and obesity and who used more medications formed cluster 2 (n=1098). Patients with less favorable levels of bone mineral density, poor cardiac and kidney function markers, and inflammation delineated cluster 3 (n=395). These three subgroups, when linked with future clinical end points, were associated with different risks of CKD progression, cardiovascular disease, and death. Furthermore, patient heterogeneity among predefined subgroups with similar baseline kidney function emerged.ConclusionsConsensus clustering synthesized the patterns of baseline clinical and laboratory measures and revealed distinct CKD subgroups, which were associated with markedly different risks of important clinical outcomes. Further examination of patient subgroups and associated biomarkers may provide next steps toward precision medicine.

Multidimensional Data Integration Identifies Tumor Necrosis Factor Activation in Nephrotic Syndrome: A Model for Precision Nephrology

“…This approach would promote an alignment of the molecular profile of the trial participants with the mechanism of action of the investigational agent. Molecular categorization could be combined with consensus clustering based on clinical and laboratory data, as outlined here for nephrotic syndrome and recently applied to the CRIC cohort 65 for precise delineation of patient prognosis and optimization of therapy.…”

Clinically Distinct Subtypes of Acute Kidney Injury on Hospital Admission Identified by Machine Learning Consensus Clustering

“…It can search for similarities and heterogeneities among large categories of data variables and isolate them into clinically meaningful clusters [8,[15][16][17]. Recent studies have shown that disease subtypes determined by ML clustering methods can forecast different clinical outcomes [18,19].…”

Machine Learning Consensus Clustering of Hospitalized Patients with Admission Hyponatremia

“…It can be used to assess similarities and differences in large datasets with many variables, and subsequently distinguish patients into novel clusters with distinct phenotypes [12,15,16]. Recent studies have demonstrated that ML consensus clustering can identify disease subtypes that carry different clinical outcomes [17,18].…”