‘Subterranean Worksick Blues’: Humour as Subversion in Two Call Centres

Abstract

This article engages in debates stimulated by previous work published in Organization Studies, and more widely, on the purpose and effects of workers' humour and joking practices. The authors emphasize the subversive character of humour in the workplace, rejecting perspectives which see humour as inevitably contributing to organizational harmony. Drawing on methodologies, including ethnography, which permitted the authors to penetrate the organizational surface of two call centres, rich evidence of satire and joking practices were uncovered. While long-acknowledged motives were revealed, particularly relief from boredom and routine, workers' use of humour took novel, call centre specific forms. Overwhelmingly, though, humour contributed to the development of vigorous countercultures in both locations, which conflicted with corporate aims and priorities. However, the particular combinations of managerial culture, attitudes to trade unionism and dissent, and the nature of oppositional groupings helped impart a different character to humour between the two call centres. At Excell, the presence of a group of activists seeking to build workplace trade unionism in circumstances of employer hostility was a crucial contrast. These activists were instrumental in their use of humour, aware that it helped make the union popular and served to weaken managerial authority. This evidence, that subversive satire can be allied to a wider collective union organizing campaign at workplace level, makes a distinctive contribution to the recent literature on organizational humour.

Upgrading Local Economies in Central and Eastern Europe? The Role of Business Service Foreign Direct Investment in the Knowledge Economy

“…In the field of employment, serious concerns have been expressed about the effects of offshoring on work in both home and host environments (Robert-Nicoud, 2008). The potential for 'backlash' in the West has been flagged by Taylor and Bain (2003) who noted campaigns in the UK to prevent the transfer of call centre jobs from the United Kingdom to India. The aspiration of policy makers in Europe, encapsulated in the Sapir Report (Year?…”

The human side of skills and knowledge

“…Yet in reality workers in front line roles may carve out spaces of freedom, misbehaviour and resistance. Engaging genuinely with those they come into contact with, joining with colleagues and customers to mock official systems and scripts or simply going through the motions of whatever acts are required for the sake of the pay packet (Bolton 2005a;Taylor and Bain 2003;Weeks 2004;Hochschild 1983). …”

The abolition of the General Teaching Council for England and the future of teacher discipline

“…The culmination of discipline and punishment according to Foucault is the Panopticon, the process of surveillance and the internalisation of discipline. Although some scholars argue that the panoptic metaphor has been over-used (Ball and Wilson, 2000;Taylor and Bain, 2003;Thompson, 2003), it remains a useful concept to investigate processes of power and control in the education sector (e.g. Selwyn, 2000;Bushnell, 2003;Piro, 2008).…”