Subterranean rodents of the genusCtenomys(Caviomorpha, Ctenomyidae) follow the converse to Bergmann's rule

Abstract

Aim We analysed body-size variation in relation to latitude, longitude, elevation and environmental variables in Ctenomys (tuco-tucos), subterranean rodents in the Ctenomyidae (Caviomorpha). We tested the existence of inter-and intraspecific size clines to determine if these rodents follow Bergmann's rule, to compare intra-and interspecific size trends and to assess the relevance of the subterranean lifestyle on these trends.Location South America, south of 15°latitude.Methods This paper is based on 719 specimens of tuco-tucos from 133 localities of Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay, representing 47 named species and 32 undescribed forms. Intraspecific analyses were performed for Ctenomys talarum Thomas, 1898 and the Ctenomys perrensi Thomas, 1896 species complex. Head and body length and weight were used for estimating body size. Geographical independent variables included latitude, longitude and altitude. Environmental independent variables were mean minimal and maximal monthly temperature, mean annual temperature, mean minimal and maximal precipitation, and total annual precipitation. To estimate seasonality, the annual variability of the climatic factors was calculated as their coefficients of variation and the difference between maximum and minimum values. Mean annual actual evapotranspiration (AET), and mean annual, January (summer) and July (winter) potential evapotranspiration (PET) values were also calculated for each locality, as well as annual, summer and winter water balance (WB). Statistical analyses consisted of simple and multiple regression and nonparametric correlation.Results Body size of Ctenomys decreases interspecifically from 15°00¢ S to 48°15¢ S and from 56°33¢ W to 71°46¢ W, and is positively correlated with ambient temperature and precipitation. The best predictors of body size according to multiple regression analyses were mean annual temperature, the difference between mean maximum and minimum annual temperatures, annual PET, the difference between summer and winter PET, and annual and winter water balance. These patterns are repeated, but not identically, at a smaller geographical scale within the species C. talarum and the superspecies C. perrensi.Main conclusions Tuco-tucos follow the converse to Bergmann's rule at the interspecific level. At the intraspecific level some parallel trends were observed, but the smaller scale of these analyses, involving a very reduced variation of environmental factors, necessitates caution in interpreting results. The subterranean lifestyle probably insulates these rodents from the external temperature. The observed latitudinal body-size gradients are more probably related to seasonality, ambient energy, primary productivity and/or intensity of predation.

A test of Allen's rule in ectotherms: the case of two south American Melanopline Grasshoppers (Orthoptera: Acrididae) with partially overlapping geographic ranges

“…Interestingly, some of the fi rst reported instances of this "inverted" empirical body size pattern seem to support Allen's rule: individuals in the cooler parts of the range tend to be smaller but also to have relatively shorter limbs (Ruibal 1955, Martof & Humphries 1959, Ray 1960). This is not, however, the case of endotherms, where body size usually increases with latitude (with exceptions; see Ashton et al 2000, Meiri & Dayan 2003, Medina et al 2007). …”

Geographic and temporal correlations of mammalian size reconsidered: a resource rule

“…Although the gray mouse-lemur (Microcebus murinus) on Madagascar has a larger mass in the slightly cooler southern end of its distribution (Lahann et al 2006), litter number increases with community production. South American burrowing rodents belonging to the genus Ctenomys have masses that increase with rainfall and temperature (Medina et al 2007), presumably tracking food quality, abundance, and availability, but in a geographical pattern opposite to Bergmann's rule. Body size in New Guinean rodents is either independent of, or decreases with, altitude, possibly because ''…food resources may diminish as ambient temperature falls'' (Taylor et al 1985).…”

The balance between predictions and evidence and the search for universal macroecological patterns: taking Bergmann’s rule back to its endothermic origin

“…The recent Watt et al's (2010) review provides a summary of the different definitions of Bergmann's rule presented in some of the main studies published since Bergmann's (1847) original formulation of the idea. Blackburn and Gaston (1996) Gaston and Blackburn (1996) Meiri and Dayan (2003) a , de Queiroz and Ashton (2004) McNab (1971), Dayan et al (1991), Medina et al (2007) II. Ectotherms…”