A recent study 1 used solution-state NMR spectroscopy to examine the interactions and dynamics of the yeast mitochondrial inner-membrane ADP/ATP carrier, yAAC3. Crystal structures of different AACs, including yAAC3, in a conformation locked with a strong inhibitor (CATR) had been determined before. This putative "c-state" 2,3 is believed to represent one extreme conformation of an alternating access mechanism, which involves a further and yet elusive second state termed "m-state". Characterizing the dynamics between these states is of paramount importance to understand the transport mechanism. The authors refolded yAAC3 from inclusion bodies in the detergent dodecylphosphocholine (DPC), and observed micro-to-millisecond (µs-ms) motion in part of yAAC3 using CPMG NMR experiments. The authors propose that this asymmetrically distributed dynamics, involving residues located in three out of six helices (α1, α2 and α6), corresponds to excursions from the c-state, which they believe is the predominant state in their sample, to an alternative state populated to 2%. They further propose that this transiently populated state might correspond to, or at least be similar to, the long-sought m-state. Support for the importance of the sparsely populated state for functional turnover comes from their finding that the dynamics is quantitatively different when the substrate (ADP) or the inhibitor (CATR) is present. As discussed below, we disagree with their interpretations. Specifically, we believe that (i) the sample was not in a functionally relevant folded state, (ii) the dynamics fits were not correctly performed and the dynamic parameters are quantitatively incorrect, and (iii) the substrate or the inhibitor have negligible effects on the dynamics in their sample, thus challenging their main conclusions.A number of studies have demonstrated the denaturing effects of DPC on AAC and related mitochondrial carriers. [4][5][6][7]