Substitution and complementarity dynamics in configurations of sustainable management practices

Abstract

PurposePrevious research tends to study various sustainable management practices (SMPs) in isolation, leading to inconsistent conclusions about the effect of SMP on firm profit. This research aims to advance the understanding of the linkage between SMP configurations and financial performance by revealing the dynamics of substitutions and complementarities among these SMPs.Design/methodology/approachThe authors conducted an exploratory study based on the theoretical lens of the practice-based view (PBV). An integrated text-mining approach is used in gathering data from 302 corporate reports of cross-sectional firms, followed by a fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis method to examine the configurations of SMPs in achieving high and low financial performance.FindingsThe findings show that green innovation practices (GIP) and cleaner production practices work together as complements for small firms in configurations associated with high profits. However, large companies in high-competition industries often adopt a minimalist configuration focusing on product quality and safety management (PQSM). PQSM and GIP are complements in configuration for small firms in high-competition industries, while they work together as substitutes for small firms in low-competition industries.Practical implicationsThis research provides managers with a new way of thinking to support decision-making in sustainable operations management. The complementary and substitutive view of management practice can guide operations managers to design and implement effective practice configurations to achieve synergistic effects.Originality/valueThis is among the first studies to reveal the complex relationship between various configurations of SMPs and firm performance. In addition, this research offers new insights into previously inconsistent findings from a PBV and configuration perspective.

Green Balanced Scorecard: A Tool of Sustainable Information Systems for an Energy Efficient Business

“…Additionally, organizations like financial institutions frequently focus on their rivals while trying to advance or strengthen their environmental and social management. As a result, sustainability management that also advances economic goals aids in the spread of the notion of sustainable development in business by providing an acceptable role model for other enterprises [6,7]. Additionally, a corporate sustainability management strategy that incorporates social and environmental concerns into regular company management guarantees that all three sustainability dimensions are considered [18,56].…”

“…Environmental protection actions may be an arm of developing a specialized know-how with large export potential and competitive advantages, generating surplus value for the economy and thousands of new jobs. In terms of environmental management, the business climate is continually changing, resulting in a new situation in which environmental commodities become economic products and enter the realm of corporate activity [7]. The economy no longer views the environment as an endless resource that is perpetually renewed and self-healing [8].…”

A Systematic Review of Sustainable Supply Chain Network Design: Optimization Approaches and Research Trends

“…The various trends in the economy, society, and environment caused by globalization, complicated trade flows, and, most importantly, sustainable development have a great impact on the configuration, design, and management of supply chain networks [3]. In light of that, many firms started adopting sustainable management practices due to the critical need for sustainability [4]. Supply chain network design (SCND) plays a significant role in supply chain performance.…”