Subjective Evaluation of Mood and Cognitive Functions in a General Neurology Clinic: Patients versus Informants

Abstract

Background and PurposeWe aimed to determine the correlation between subjective evaluations of mood and cognitive functions by patients and informants, and the findings of a battery of neuropsychological tests.MethodsWe analyzed 74 subjects recruited from a general neurology clinic, comprising 37 patients with cognitive complaints and 37 informants (either relatives or caregivers in close contact with the patients). Four ordinal scales concerning recent memory, verbal expression, initiative, and mood were correlated with the findings of a series of neuropsychological tests and questionnaires using the tau b coefficient.ResultsThe scores for the patients on the scales were most strongly correlated with scores on the 15-item Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS-15), while the scores for the informants were most strongly correlated with scores on GDS-15, the Informant Questionnaire on Cognitive Decline, and the Functional Activities Questionnaire (FAQ). The most significant correlation was between the initiative scale from informants and FAQ (tau b=-0.591, p<0.001), and it was the only one that remained significant after correcting for multiple testing (p Holm=0.013).ConclusionsCognitive complaints from patients mainly reflect their mood, whilst informant reports mainly reflect both the functional ability and mood of the patients.

Validation of online functional measures in cognitively impaired older adults

“…In future studies it will be important to include additional subjective measures, such as basic ADLs, cognitive complaints, memory concerns, and behavioral and neuropsychiatric symptoms. These additional measures, which are being collected as part of the BHR study, may confer additional predictive power 39‐44 …”

The effect of self-assessed fatigue and subjective cognitive impairment on work capacity: The case of multiple sclerosis

“…Ordinal scales have been shown to be useful for evaluating other subjective symptoms, including cognition, as the obtained scores can be readily analyzed using standard statistical tests. 41 In our study, the use of simple questions is justified by the length of the survey questionnaire, the large sample and the complete anonymity of the participants, and thus the uncontrolled conditions during which patients completed the survey. Most importantly, however, our purpose was to investigate how the respondents judged these problems and their impact on their employment, not to clinically assess fatigue and cognition.…”

Online study partner‐reported cognitive decline in the Brain Health Registry

“…SP report of decline is also reliably associated with magnitude of cognitive impairment determined from neuropsychological assessment [13,14]. The same relationship is not observed as consistently for self‐reported cognitive decline, where factors such as depressed mood [15–17] and lack of awareness associated with dementia limits its usefulness [14,18,19]. SP report of impairment is associated moderately with abnormal levels of AD biomarkers, such as positron emission tomography amyloid burden and hippocampal volume [3,20–22].…”