Subjective cognitive complaints and subjective cognition following electroconvulsive therapy for depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

Background: Subjective cognitive complaints represent a leading reason for suboptimal prescription of electroconvulsive therapy, the most acutely effective treatment for depression. However, research findings regarding their presentation are conflicting. Objective: To describe, quantify and explain the variability in subjective cognitive complaints and subjective cognition following electroconvulsive therapy for depression. Methods: We searched systematically PubMed, Embase, PsycARTICLES, CINAHL and relevant reviews for research published from 1 January 1972 to 31 August 2020. We included all independent studies of patients whose subjective cognition was assessed following brief-pulse electroconvulsive therapy for depression. Three meta-analyses were conducted to quantify: (1) the prevalence of patients presenting with cognitive complaints following electroconvulsive therapy; (2) the pre–post electroconvulsive therapy change in subjective cognition and (3) the association between change in depressive symptoms and change in cognitive complaints. Effect sizes were calculated using random-effects models. Eight prespecified demographic and clinical moderators of between-study variability were assessed using sub-group analyses and meta-regressions. Results: Data from 72 studies including 5699 participants were meta-analysed. Weighted mean prevalence of patients with cognitive complaints was 48.1% (95% confidence interval = [42.3%, 53.9%]). The type of subjective measure used significantly impacted the pre–post electroconvulsive therapy change in subjective cognition, showing, respectively, large improvement ( g = 0.81; 95% confidence interval = [0.59, 1.03]) after electroconvulsive therapy with the Squire Self-Rating Scale of Memory and small worsening (g = –0.48; 95% confidence interval = [–0.70, –0.26]) with 1-item memory scales. The strongest predictors of improved post-electroconvulsive therapy subjective cognition were increased age and larger post-electroconvulsive therapy decrease in depressive symptoms. The weighted mean correlation between pre–post electroconvulsive therapy decrease in depressive symptoms and pre–post electroconvulsive therapy decrease in cognitive complaints was 0.46 (95% confidence interval = [0.39, 0.53]). Conclusion: Variability in subjective cognition following electroconvulsive therapy is mostly explained by the degree of post-treatment persisting depression and by the subjective assessment used. Scales measuring exclusively subjective worsening present limited clinical utility and instruments allowing the detection of both improvement and worsening in subjective cognition should be preferred.

Trajectories of Efficacy and Cognitive Function During Electroconvulsive Therapy Course in Young Adults with Treatment-Resistant Depression

“…This result is consistent with a recent study showing that the number of ECT was associated with subjective cognition: more sessions received, higher prevalence of complaints. 45 Furthermore, subjective cognitive complaints did not decrease over time following treatment. 45 There are several possible reasons.…”

“… 45 Furthermore, subjective cognitive complaints did not decrease over time following treatment. 45 There are several possible reasons. First, we used bitemporal ECT, which is usually considered to be associated with more cognitive effects than unilateral ECT.…”

“…First, we used bitemporal ECT, which is usually considered to be associated with more cognitive effects than unilateral ECT. 45 Second, younger patients with more depressive symptoms overreported cognitive impairments. 64 , 66 , 67 The patients in our study were young adults who have greater access to the media and internet and who may have learned about the side-effects of ECT to negatively affect their expectations.…”

“…As SMI was an ordinal variable, CLMM was performed, subgroup, visit, and the subgroup*visit interaction as included as fixed factors, and odds ratios (Ors) and their 95% Cis were used to examine whether the change in SMI increased with ECT treatment. Age, charge, and pulse width 45 , 46 were included as covariates in both MMRM and CLMM to control for potential confounders.…”

Effectiveness of electroconvulsive therapy in patients lacking decision making capacity: A systematic review and meta-analysis

“…Against the background of these limitations, no firm conclusions can be drawn from our meta-analysis regarding possibly differential cognitive side effects between the groups. However, the available data suggest an at least equal cognitive tolerability in patients without DMC-T. An assessment of patients' perspectives post ECT [17], subjective measures of cognition [68], or level of functioning as a surrogate marker for cognitive function in daily life may yield additional evidence on the effect of ECT on cognition in patients lacking DMC-T.…”