Subject to qualification: Weakening links between job roles and qualifications in Australian manufacturing enterprise agreements

Abstract

This article examines job classifications in enterprise agreements from the Australian manufacturing industry, focusing on the recognition of formal qualifications. It follows earlier research that found the strength and frequency of references to qualifications vary considerably between modern awards, with manufacturing industry awards having some of the strongest connections. A representative sample of 350 agreements (13.5% of the total) made under the Fair Work Act between 2010 and 2013 was analysed. Analysis revealed that linkages between formal qualifications and job classification structures are less common in enterprise agreements than in relevant modern awards. However, the overall effects of enterprise bargaining on recognition of employees' qualifications are complex. We find that, one way or another, the award classification structure continues to apply in 47.1% of enterprise agreements. Through logistic regression, we explore factors influencing the use of formal qualifications as part of job classifications, with a particular focus on whether this extends beyond the licensing requirements of tradespeople (Certificate III). Our finding that three factors – workplace size, award coverage and union coverage – significantly affect enterprise bargaining outcomes is likely to be generalisable beyond this study's focus on job classifications to many other important terms in enterprise agreements.

The economic globalization for sustainable management of overseas trade enterprise logistics

“…Because international transportation often has greater risks, enterprises with more registered capital are guaranteed, who can deliver the goods in time and ensure the safety of goods. In this regard, large enterprises have a strong guarantee (Oliver & Walpole, 2018). Large‐scale third‐party logistics service enterprises involve a wide range of customers, and each customer's requirements are different.…”

“…Because international transportation often has greater risks, enterprises with more registered capital are guaranteed, who can deliver the goods in time and ensure the safety of goods. In this regard, large enterprises have a strong guarantee (Oliver & Walpole, 2018).…”

The Australian labour market in 2018

“…One shift from previous periods of economic recovery is that, because workers' pay power has eroded, firms can deploy greater differentiation in pay rates, giving pay increases to retain favoured workers and attract new workers without having to increase overall going rates (Haldane, 2018: 10). Certainly this would be the case in the Australian context, where the decline in collective bargaining coverage facilitates greater discretion in pay setting by management (Oliver and Walpole, 2018). Haldane also credits automation and monopolistic competition as two accelerating trends suppressing wage growth.…”

Australian industrial relations in 2018: Inequality, policy stagnation and a brewing storm

“…They suggest that contributors to this disparity include structural problems with collective bargaining, particularly in small and medium enterprises and fissured workplaces, as well as restrictions on industrial action (McCrystal, 2019). Oliver and Yu (2019) note that businesses are exercising greater discretion in pay setting due to the decline in collective bargaining (see also Oliver and Walpole, 2018). Williamson et al (2019) note continued workplace inequality along gender lines despite a decade (and more) of reforms designed to narrow the gap.…”