Studies on the second victim phenomenon and other related topics in the pan-European environment: The experience of ERNST Consortium members

Abstract

Background Patient safety is a priority worldwide. When things go wrong in the provision of patient care, the healthcare professionals involved can be psychologically affected (second victims, SVs). Recently, different initiatives have been launched to address this phenomenon. Aim To identify through the ERNST Pan-European Consortium the current study lines in Europe on SVs and other topics related to how the lack of well-being of healthcare professionals can affect the quality of care. Methods A cross-sectional study was conducted based on an ad hoc online survey. All 82 academics and clinicians who had formalized their membership to the COST Action 19113 by September 2020 and represented 27 European and one neighboring country were invited to participate. The survey consisted of 19 questions that explored the participants’ scientific profile, their interests, and previous experiences in the SVs’ topic, and related areas of work in Europe. Results Seventy (85.4%) COST Action members responded to the survey. Thirty-seven (37.1%) had conducted SV studies in the past or were doing so at the moment of the survey. Seventeen participants were involved in implementing interventions to support SVs. Future lines of study included legal issues, open disclosure, training programs, and patient safety curricula. Conclusions Studies have been conducted in Europe on the magnitude of the SV phenomenon and the usefulness of some techniques to promote resilience among healthcare professionals. New gaps have been identified. The COST Action 19113 aims to foster European collaboration to reinforce the healthcare professionals’ well-being and thus contribute to patient safety.

Emotional Responses and Support Needs of Healthcare Professionals after Adverse or Traumatic Experiences in Healthcare—Evidence from Seminars on Peer Support

“…The ERNST (European Researchers' Network Working on Second Victims) Consortium identified current lines of study in Europe on the phenomenon of second victims to provide an approximate overview of second victim research and support programmes. They identified seventeen ongoing interventions to support second victims [15]. In Denmark, we have developed, implemented, and evaluated a peer-support programme, The Buddy Study, in two departments at Odense University Hospital.…”

Key factors for effective implementation of healthcare workers support interventions after patient safety incidents in health organisations: a scoping review

“…A study published in 2020 shows that the most prevalent symptoms in HCWs after PSIs were troubling memories, anxiety/concern and anger toward themselves 9. Work satisfaction, confidence in their abilities2 and work performance7 10 can also be seriously impacted by these types of incidents. It can result in turnover intentions and absenteeism11 and in the most severe cases can lead to suicide 12…”

Mentorship in patient safety: Do we need a new approach?

“…Carillo and colleagues describe the recently launched ERNST Pan-European Consortium, which fosters collaboration to reinforce the well-being of health professionals, and thus contributes to patient safety. 22 Carefully directed mentorship by senior clinicians could help promote development of both individual resilience and well-being in their mentees, as well as a culture of safety.…”