Students’ Metacognitive Weaknesses in Academic Writing: A Preliminary Research

Abstract

This article aims to explain the weaknesses of metacognition that affect writing skills. Weaknesses of writing like content development, the organization of writing, compatibility of content with themes and audience awareness are assumed from the weaknesses of student metacognition. By using a qualitative approach, data is collected through questionnaires and interviews. Using the questionnaire found the level of student metacognitive awareness. A total of 22 male and female students were randomly selected. Responses given through self-report questionnaires showed that as many as 15 students had high metacognitive awareness and as many as 7 students had low metacognitive awareness. Furthermore, through interviews found metacognitive skills in academic writing. The results of the data analysis show that there are three weaknesses of student metacognitive, namely: students are too dependent on feedback from lecturers and highly dependent on lecturers and colleagues when writing, students cannot assess their own understanding of the information they receive for writing assignments, students are not aware benefit from the strategies used during writing. Students need to be trained to plan, monitor and evaluate writing activities so that they are skilled in arranging words, concepts, and terminology used in writing. In addition, through the writing they produce, it can be seen how the process of produces the meaning and thinking skills of students in writing.

From Pandemic to New Normal: Portraying EFL Graduates’ Metacognitive Strategy in Thesis Writing

“…The findings are consistent with previous studies stating that students sought help from webs, classmates, and teachers (Maftoon et al, 2014;Ramadhanti et al, 2019). The finding highlighted that discussing with classmates brought a significant effect to improve the quality of writing.…”

Mind Mapping in Learning Models: A Tool to Improve Student Metacognitive Skills

“…Metacognitive skills are important to train students because they help to monitor cognitive activities, such as planning, monitoring, and evaluating the learning process [24]. Practicing metacognitive skills can be done using learning strategies such as mind mapping.…”

Revising with Metacognition to Promote Writing Achievement

“…Furthermore, students who are tasked with practicing their metacognitive skills can learn how to enhance them, leading to increased writing achievement and independence. For example, when Ramadhanti, Ghazali, Hasanah, and Harsiati (2019) surveyed students at an Indonesian university with a Metacognitive Awareness Inventory, they uncovered weaknesses that affected performance. The researchers assert that increased awareness of "thinking processes while learning" will result in students' ability to regulate "their goals, dispositions, interests, and attention in learning" (p. 51).…”