Student perceptions of quality in higher education: effect of year of study, gender and ethnicity.

Abstract

Student expectations with regard to what comprises quality in higher education can impact upon their learning, engagement and overall satisfaction. Perceptions of quality are not always clearly articulated and may vary by gender, ethnicity and year of study. In this study, undergraduate students completed a questionnaire indicating whether they agreed, disagreed or were unsure about 15 statements related to quality in higher education. A total of 340 students across four year groups participated (Levels 3-6), with more female than male participants and a range of ethnicities represented. There was broad unanimity in the recognition of the importance of both teaching and learning and relationships with academic staff in defining quality. Overall, there were low levels of satisfaction with the amount of contact with academic staff and uncertainty about whether students thought they were getting a high quality education. Some differences in relation to support services were seen in different ethnic groups, and more males than females were satisfied with support services although this varied by year group, and student numbers were small. These results suggest the importance of clearly articulating what is available in terms of support (academic, pastoral, study and health) to all students. The teaching and learning experience, and relationships with academic staff are clearly important and given the uncertainty about overall perceptions of quality, these aspects need to be highlighted to students so that they understand the value of what they are receiving.Keywords: quality, perceptions, relationships, feedback, teaching & learning

COVID-19 and the move to online teaching: impact on perceptions of belonging in staff and students in a UK widening participation university

“…In schools, the relationships between staff members feed into the culture and ethos of the school and thus have a major impact on student achievement (Barth, 2006). There is no reason to suppose it would be different in higher education, and in university students, relationships with academic staff are highly valued both as part of student belonging (Dwyer, 2017), and as a marker of institutional quality (Dicker et al, 2017(Dicker et al, , 2018. Ensuring that relationships may be nurtured without face-to-face contact will be a challenge, especially for new students starting in September with whom entirely new relationships need to be formed.…”

Active learning across disciplines: opportunities to develop employability skills and leadership potential in undergraduate students. A student and staff perspective.

“…Student partners identified being able to work closely with staff partners as one of the main reasons they got involved. Students have been shown to value relationships with academics most highly followed by interactions with their peers (Dicker et al, 2017), when identifying markers of what constitutes high quality higher education. The integration of staff research into undergraduate student teaching is quite commonplace in higher education, although undergraduate and postgraduate views on such can be both positive and negative (Lindsay et al, 2002).…”

The Influence of Teachers’ Competence Toward the Learning Outcome of Students from the Beauty Department in a Vocational High School in Semarang

“…In this case, qualitative and quantitative responses suggested that students recognise the contribution of lecturers and teaching and learning provision to their overall experience, which is in agreement with others (Neves & Hillman, 2016). As in Dicker,et al,most (95%) of the students surveyed agreed with the statement that 'the lecturers I have an impact upon my learning' (Dicker et al, 2017).…”