Student ideas regarding entropy and the second law of thermodynamics in an introductory physics course

Abstract

We report on students' thinking regarding entropy in an introductory calculus-based physics course. We analyzed students' responses to a variety of questions on entropy changes of an arbitrarily defined system and its surroundings. In four offerings of the same course we found that before instruction, no more than 6% of all students could give completely correct responses to relevant questions posed in both general and concrete contexts. Nearly two-thirds of the students showed clear evidence of conservation-type reasoning regarding entropy. These outcomes were little changed even after instruction. Targeted instruction that guided students to recognize that entropy is not a conserved quantity appears to yield improved performance on qualitative questions related to this concept. Disciplines Physics | Scholarship of Teaching and Learning CommentsThis article is from American Journal of Physics 77 (2009) We report on students' thinking regarding entropy in an introductory calculus-based physics course. We analyzed students' responses to a variety of questions on entropy changes of an arbitrarily defined system and its surroundings. In four offerings of the same course we found that before instruction, no more than 6% of all students could give completely correct responses to relevant questions posed in both general and concrete contexts. Nearly two-thirds of the students showed clear evidence of conservation-type reasoning regarding entropy. These outcomes were little changed even after instruction. Targeted instruction that guided students to recognize that entropy is not a conserved quantity appears to yield improved performance on qualitative questions related to this concept.

More than Meets the Eye – Infrared Cameras in Open-Ended University Thermodynamics Labs

“…Entropy is yet another thermodynamics concept that is challenging for students to grasp. 16 In a typical metal, an increase in temperature results in an expanding material, due to the energy added to the crystalline bonds. In contrast, by controlling the temperature of an elastic rubber band an increased temperature yields a counterintuitive decrease in volume since the cross-linked polymer molecules behave as entropic springs with a spring constant that increases with temperature.…”

Confronting Conceptual Challenges in Thermodynamics by Use of Self-Generated Analogies

“…In this respect, if there is adiabatic, reversible change, then the entropy is constant, but if it is irreversible, then the entropy increases. Christensen, Meltzer and Ogilvie (2009) performed an extensive study on students' conceptions of entropy and the second law of thermodynamics as expressed in problem solving regarding thermal processes. Their main finding was that the idea that the entropy of a system and its surrounding is conserved in spontaneous processes is one of the most common misunderstandings among students, for instance during free expansion of an ideal gas where the gas in a container is allowed to expand into a vacuum and the entropy actually increases.…”

“…Even though it may be used productively in teaching, this conception is not without its flaws. It may even reinforce misconceptions, such as the idea that entropy is a conserved quantity (Christensen et al, 2009). In order to avoid the idiosyncratic character of each individual analogy, Spiro et al (1989) suggest the use of a coherent set of multiple analogies in the teaching of complex subject matter, in their case muscle physiology.…”

Experts’ understanding of partial derivatives using the partial derivative machine

“…Furthermore, which of these variables are independent and which are dependent varies with the context. In particular, the conjugate pair associated with heating, namely, temperature and entropy, is known to be troublesome for students [8].…”