Structural changes in the Russian health care system: do they match European trends?

Abstract

Вackground In the last two decades, health care systems (HCS) in the European countries have faced global challenges and have undergone structural changes with the focus on early disease prevention, strengthening primary care, changing the role of hospitals, etc. Russia has inherited the Semashko model from the USSR with dominance of inpatient care, and has been looking for the ways to improve the structure of service delivery. This paper compares the complex of structural changes in the Russian and the European HCS. Methods We address major developments in four main areas of medical care delivery: preventive activities, primary care, inpatient care, long-term care. Our focus is on the changes in the organizational structure and activities of health care providers, and in their interaction to improve service delivery. To describe the ongoing changes, we use both qualitative characteristics and quantitative indicators. We extracted the relevant data from the national and international databases and reports and calculated secondary estimates. We also used data from our survey of physicians and interviews with top managers in medical care system. Results The main trends of structural changes in Russia HCS are similar to the changes in most EU countries. The prevention and the early detection of diseases have developed intensively. The reduction in hospital bed capacity and inpatient care utilization has been accompanied by a decrease in the average length of hospital stay. Russia has followed the European trend of service delivery concentration in hospital-physician complexes, while the increase in the average size of hospitals is even more substantial. However, distinctions in health care delivery organization in Russia are still significant. Changes in primary care are much less pronounced, the system remains hospital centered. Russia lags behind the European leaders in terms of horizontal ties between providers. The reasons for inadequate structural changes are rooted in the governance of service delivery. Conclusion The structural transformations must be intensified with the focus on strengthening primary care, further integration of care, and development of new organizational structures that mitigate the dependence on inpatient care.

Preventable mortality in the Russian Federation: a retrospective, regional level study

“… 64 At the same time, the healthcare system remains heavily hospital-focused with an overall number of bed-days per capita that is 70–75% higher than in the EU. 65 Furthermore, we do not find evidence that our proxy variable for alcohol consumption was associated with a reduction in overall preventable mortality. This finding could be attributed to three things.…”

The hard way from the Beveridge to the Bismarck model of health finance: Expectations and reality in Russia

“…The rates are usually adjusted for hospitals that lose revenue under this method. The so-called “coefficients of DRG” are determined for such hospitals ( 13 ).…”

“…Regional MHI funds encourage the deployment of day care centers by increasing their reimbursement rates. The share of patients treated in day wards in the total number of patients treated in hospitals increased from 7.6% in 2000 to 20.8% in 2018 ( 18 ).…”

“…State-owned polyclinics and hospitals do not pay for major equipment as a result of its poor responsibility for their rational use. There are many examples of the underutilization of this equipment ( 13 ). This funding pattern also discriminates against private providers who are involved in MHI.…”

Evaluation of Continuity of Care: What Can Physician Survey Add?

“…This facilitates but does not guarantee teamwork and continuity of care [14]. 2) The hospital sector is built as a multilevel system, with rural, central rayon, city, regional and federal hospitals closely linked through a referral system from one level to another, while outpatient and inpatient care is usually provided by different doctors [15]. 3) The distinction between acute and long-term hospitals does not exist in Russia.…”