While there is evidence that the two ubiquitously expressed thyroid hormone (T3) receptors, TR␣1 and TR1, have distinct functional specificities, the mechanism by which they discriminate potential target genes remains largely unexplained. In this study, we demonstrate that the thyroid hormone response elements (TRE) from the malic enzyme and myelin basic protein genes (ME TRE and MBP TRE ) respectively, are not functionally equivalent. The ME TRE , which is a direct repeat motif with a 4-base pair gap between the two half-site hexamers binds thyroid hormone receptor as a heterodimer with 9-cis-retinoic acid receptor (RXR) and mediates a high T3-dependent activation in response to TR␣1 or TR1 in NIH3T3 cells. In contrast, the MBP TRE , which consists of an inverted palindrome formed by two hexamers spaced by 6 base pairs, confers an efficient transactivation by TR1 but a poor transactivation by TR␣1. While both receptors form heterodimers with RXR on MBP TRE , the poor transactivation by TR␣1 correlates also with its ability to bind efficiently as a monomer. This monomer, which is only observed with TR␣1 bound to MBP TRE , interacts neither with N-CoR nor with SRC-1, explaining its functional inefficacy. However, in Xenopus oocytes, in which RXR proteins are not detectable, the transactivation mediated by TR␣1 and TR1 is equivalent and independent of a RXR supply, raising the question of the identity of the thyroid hormone receptor partner in these cells. Thus, in mammalian cells, the binding characteristics of TR␣1 to MBP TRE (i.e. high monomer binding efficiency and low transactivation activity) might explain the particular pattern of T3 responsiveness of MBP gene expression during central nervous system development.
Thyroid hormone receptors (TRs)1 are transcription factors that belong to the steroid/thyroid nuclear receptor superfamily, which are encoded by two distinct genes, c-erbA␣ and c-erbA. Alternative splicing of the ␣ gene primary transcripts at their 3Ј extremity generates mRNAs encoding TR␣1, which binds thyroid hormone (triiodothyronine; T3), as well as the c-erbA␣2 and c-erbA␣3 variants, which do not. The  gene expresses two T3-binding isoforms, TR1 and the minor form TR2 (reviewed in Ref. 1). In the adult animal, the ␣1 and 1 receptor mRNAs are found in all T3-sensitive tissues, albeit with differences in their relative abundance (2, 3). In contrast, expression of the two receptor isotypes is strikingly different during brain development. Whereas TR␣1 expression predominates at early stages and remains steady, TR1 expression is initially very low but exhibits a dramatic transient increase during the critical period of the central nervous system maturation (4 -6). At this moment, 1 transcripts prevail in the proliferation layer, while those of ␣1 are localized in the differentiation layer of the developing rat cerebral cortex. These patterns of expression are consistent with specific functions of the two receptors in brain development (7-9).TR transactivation activities are mediated thr...