Simultaneous achievement of lightweight, high strength, large fracture strain, and high damping capability has been challenging because some of these mechanical properties are mutually exclusive. Here, we have utilized self-assembled polymeric carbon precursor materials in combination with scalable nanoimprinting lithography to produce nanoporous carbon nanopillars. The produced amorphous carbon nanopillars exhibited ultrahigh strength similar to or even higher than one tenth of their Young's modulus (E), the most widely used approximation of a fundamental upper limit of material breaking strength. Remarkably, nanoporosity induced via sacrificial template significantly reduced the mass density of amorphous carbon to 0.66~0.82g/cm3 while the strength of E/10 is still maintained. Moreover, these nanopillars displayed both elastic and plastic behavior with large fracture strain. A reversible part of the sp2-to-sp3 transition produces large elastic strain and a high loss factor (up to 0.033) comparable to Ni-Ti shape memory alloys. The irreversible part of the sp2-to-sp3 transition enables plastic deformation, leading to a large fracture strain of up to 35%. These findings have been substantiated using simulation studies. None of the existing structural materials exhibit a comparable combination of density, strength, deformability, and damping capability. Hence, the results of this study illustrate the potential of both dense and nanoporous amorphous carbon materials as superior structural nanomaterials.