Stress and anxiety management strategies in health professions' simulation training: a review of the literature

Abstract

IntroductionSimulation training has been used to teach clinical skills to health profession trainees. Stress and/or anxiety occur in high-acuity scenarios in the clinical environment, and affect clinician performance and patient outcomes. To date, strategies that have been used in conjunction with simulation training for healthcare professionals that address stress management are limited. This paper reports a literature review conducted to explore strategies used with simulations to enhance the ability of health profession trainees in reducing acute stress and/or anxiety during high-acuity clinical events.MethodsDatabases searched included Scopus, PubMed, CINAHL, Web of Knowledge and Science Direct. The examples of the literature chosen were those published in the English language from January 2005 to March 2015, and were peer-reviewed empirical papers that focused on the strategies addressing stress and/or anxiety during simulation training for healthcare profession trainees.ResultsEight studies using various forms of stress/anxiety management strategies with simulations demonstrated varying degrees of effectiveness. Themes that emerged from these eight studies were excessive stress and clinical performance in simulation, emotional training strategies in simulation, and factors contributing to stress and anxiety reduction during simulation.ConclusionsExcessive stress and/or anxiety in the clinical setting have been shown to affect performance and could compromise patient outcomes. Health profession training curricula might benefit from a stress/anxiety reduction strategy integrated into the simulation programmes. This review showed that the stress/anxiety management strategies that have been used with simulations, mostly in surgical training, have various degrees of effectiveness.

Psychological Adjustment of Healthcare Workers in Italy during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Differences in Stress, Anxiety, Depression, Burnout, Secondary Trauma, and Compassion Satisfaction between Frontline and Non-Frontline Professionals

“…The literature suggests that medical staff treating patients with COVID-19 report high levels of anxiety and low self-efficacy levels [39,40], and other research on Wuhan healthcare workers reported great vulnerability to stress, anxiety, and depression, suggesting that frontline healthcare workers should be closely monitored as a high-risk group for maladjustment [29]. Excessive stress and/or anxiety in the clinical context may affect performance and can compromise patient outcomes [41].…”

Understanding Stress in Communication Management: How It Limits the Effectiveness at Personal and Organizational Level

“…There are many theories on physical processes and external types of stressors. These may be categorized in two ways: "systemic" stress these are based on psychobiology, and physiology [11] and mental stress developed within the field of cognitive psychology [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14].…”

“…Programs used with simulations to enhance the coping skills of health profession trainees in reducing stress and anxiety have shown increased levels of effectiveness during high anxiety clinical situations [9]. Effectiveness of a theory-based online intervention to help undergraduate students cope with the stress management has shown shows positive results [10].…”

Novel Otolaryngology Simulation for the Management of Emergent Oropharyngeal Hemorrhage

“…By being encouraged to voice concerns during an emergency, trainees can act as partners in the reduction of possible medical errors. Further, in a literature review by Ignacio et al, it was found that "excessive stress and/or anxiety in the clinical setting have been shown to affect performance and could compromise patient outcomes [22]." In and out of the field of medicine, studies have "suggested that stress training showed an improving trend in performance….…”

“…[and was a] valuable strategy for enhancing… thought process and improving… performance in communication skills [22]." By presenting the junior residents with a stressful situation in which an attending suggests a management option that might not be appropriate for the patient, the residents learn how to properly and respectfully suggest an alternate treatment approach, while also learning the technical skills needed to properly care for such a patient.…”